Kathleen Gilbert

On Thanksgiving, Obama thanks ‘choices,’ not God

Kathleen Gilbert

Last year, I took issue with the fact that Barack Obama’s Thanksgiving proclamation was the first in US history to mention God only obliquely, and otherwise could have been delivered by an atheist. Considering that the Thanksgiving proclamation is perhaps the clearest governmental tradition by which America’s religious roots are acknowledged, it was a subtle shift worth noting, particularly for a figure who seems to have trouble convincing people that he belongs to the faith he says he does.

Obama’s Thanksgiving proclamation this year, fortunately, is much more God-laden than the last. However, in his “Thanksgiving greeting,” our president largely puts aside all that God business for the important things: progress(ivism), and politics - including another call for a “real and honest discussion” with Republican leaders. (Remember how refreshing the last “honest discussion” was?).

Typical Obamalinksy speak aside, the tone of Obama’s “thanksgiving” is curious. “God” in the form of “God-given bounty” makes an appearance here, but then the president reveals the real source of our prosperity: us! Of course Divine Providence cooperates, but given Obama’s conclusion one wonders: who, exactly, is he thanking?:

This is also a holiday that captures that distinctly American impulse to give something of ourselves. ... [T]hat’s emblematic of what Americans have always done.  We come together and do what’s required to make tomorrow better than today.  That’s who we are.

We are among the world’s youngest of peoples, but time and again, we have boldly and resiliently led the way forward.  Against tough odds, we are a people who endure – who explored and settled a vast and untamed continent; who built a powerful economy and stood against tyranny in all its forms; who marched and fought for equality, and connected a globe with our own science and imagination.

None of that progress was predestined.  None of it came easily.  Instead, the blessings for which we give thanks today are the product of choices made by our parents, and grandparents, and generations before – whose determination and sacrifice ensured a better future for us.

When blessings are the product of our own “choices,” who needs God?


Truth. Delivered daily.

Get FREE pro-life, pro-family news delivered straight to your inbox. 

Select Your Edition:

Share this article


A Thanksgiving pro-life story: the archbishop and the adoption

Kathleen Gilbert
By Kathleen Gilbert

Enjoy this beautiful Thanksgiving story courtesy of Wisconsin Right to Life’s “Pass This On” series: When a Wisconsin mother learns that her unborn daughter is disabled, her doctor pressures her to abort her and ease the stress on their family, which already cares for a severely disabled child.  But with miraculous help from future New York Archbishop (and USCCB President-to-be) Timothy Dolan, the mother chooses life - and makes an infertile couple’s dreams come true.

Share this article


Customize your experience.

Login with Facebook