Thursday February 12, 2004
ACLU/Doctors Challenge Partial Birth Abortion Ban
Judge Stymies U.S. Justice Department Bid to Argue that the 'Health' of Women was Never an Issue
CHICAGO, February 12, 2004 (LifeSiteNews.com) - A US federal judge in Chicago has restricted the federal Justice Department's access to medical records in Illinois which it requested in its bid to defend the partial birth abortion ban. The Judge and hospitals cite a breach of patient confidentiality as the issue.
The American Civil Liberties Union and a group of Doctors is suing the federal Justice Department over charges that the partial birth abortion ban implemented late last year is unconstitutional. The group argues that the ban does not allow an exception for the procedure "if it is needed to protect the mother's life."
The US Department of Justice seeks to determine if the procedure was necessary to save the lives of the women who had the partial birth abortions performed at the hands of the doctors involved in the case.
The US Department of Justice has subpoenaed the medical records of the patients of the seven doctors involved in the suit. U.S. Chief District Judge Charles P. Kocoras has denied the request, despite the assurance from the Justice Department that names and any other identifying information could be withheld. Officials said that government lawyers commonly subpoena medical records with names and other identifying information withheld for other types of cases, such as fraud.
On the other hand, U.S. District Judge Richard Casey, who is hearing the case in New York, was frustrated by the lack of cooperation from the hospitals. An attorney for the plaintiffs told Judge Casey that the doctors cannot force hospitals to surrender their records, to which Judge Casey replied "I will not let the doctors hide behind the shield of the hospital. They didn't have to be plaintiffs. They chose to be, and now they are going to get it done."
The partial birth abortion ban, implemented by President George W. Bush in November 2003, outlaws a procedure carried out after the first trimester of pregnancy called "intact dilation and extraction", which consists of delivering a baby its head crushed, usually during an otherwise normal birth. The head is first caved in, in order that the baby be born lifeless and silent.
The suit is one of three filed last November by the National Abortion Federation after President Bush signed the ban into law.
Read related LifeSiteNews.com coverage from South Carolina at: http://www.lifesitenews.com/ldn/2003/apr/030429.html
Read local coverage at:
http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/chi-0402120342feb12,1,2450045.sto...
Latest Headlines
- "Manhattan Declaration" Embodies U.S. Christian Pushback against Abortion, Same-Sex "Marriage"

- Hoffman Loses Final Tally of NY-23 Race; Alleges ACORN Tampering and Fraud

- Abortion Activist Judge Hamilton Confirmed with Help of Ten Republican Senators

- CDC Reverses Gardasil Vaccine Requirement for Immigrants

- Germany Faces Economic Downturn with Plummeting Birth Rate and Aging Population

- CCHD in Archdiocese of Chicago Says it is Working to Fix Problems

- Rejection of Washington DC Marriage Referendum Challenged With Legal Suit

- Obama-Supporting Homosexual Activist to Out Sexually Involved Priests Unless they Support Gay 'Marriage

- Austrian Catholic Bishops Issue Bland Response to Govt's Homosexual Partnership Bill

- Interim Report on Catholic Sex-Abuse Says "Homosexual Identity" Not a Predictor of Sex Abuse

- Commentary on Nov 20 NewsBytes

- LSN NewsBytes - US Health Care Reform

- LSN NewsBytes - Catholic Campaign for Human Development (CCHD)

- LSN NewsBytes - Life Issues, Religion, Swine Flu, US Politics, Sarah Palin, Miscellaneous

- LSN NewsBytes - Climate Change/Global Warming

- 59 Bishops Contributed Financially to Maine Bishop's Effort to Oppose Maine Same-Sex "Marriage" Law

- Pro-Abortion Lawmakers Shower Praise on Senate Bill's Phony Abortion Compromise

Most Read this Week
- Largest U.S. Homosexual Publisher Shuts Down, Closing Major Gay Newspapers
- EWTN's Arroyo Hosts Reform CCHD Reps Who Reveal Shocking Evidence Against USCCB Anti-Poverty Arm
- Italian Mayors Order Crufixes Put in Classrooms in Revolt against European Court Ruling
- Nat'l Organization for Marriage Responds to Miss California "Sex Tape" Scandal
- Obama Evades Questioning on Stupak Amendment in FOX Interview
- "Manhattan Declaration" Embodies U.S. Christian Pushback against Abortion, Same-Sex "Marriage"
- French Judge Finds Hospital Guilty of "Unreasonable Obstinacy" in Saving Newborn's Life
- EU Leaders to Choose President today in Secret "Soviet Style" Meetings
- Hoffman "Unconcedes" Battle for NY-23: Recount Provides Hope for "Miracle" Victory
- CCHD Responds to Reform Movement
MORE NEWS:
LifeSiteNews.com Home Page
Last 10 Days
Archives
Special Reports
Copyright © LifeSiteNews.com. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivatives License. You may republish this article or portions of it without request provided the content is not altered and it is clearly attributed to "LifeSiteNews.com". Any website publishing of complete or large portions of original LifeSiteNews articles MUST additionally include a live link to www.LifeSiteNews.com. The link is not required for excerpts. Republishing of articles on LifeSiteNews.com from other sources as noted is subject to the conditions of those sources.








Back to Top