Politics
Wednesday June 30, 2004
"Embryonic" Stem Cell Study for Parkinson's Disease No Breakthrough - Cells are from Aborted Babies
TODAY'S HEADLINES
E-MAIL
PRINT
June 30, 2004 (LifeSiteNews.com) - A team of scientists has published the results of a series of embryo cell transplants in Parkinson's patients. The outcome of the research is being touted by Reuters as a breakthrough, but careful examination of the article reveals ambiguous results.
Dr. Paul H. Gordon of New York-Presbyterian Hospital/Columbia University Medical Center led a team of scientists in a test that involved two sets of Parkinson's patients. One set received a sham surgery as a control group and the other received implantation of embryonic cells. The article is ambiguous about the nature of the cells used.
Embryologists call an "embryo" the child from the first day to about 8 weeks development. The article that appeared online in the scientific journal, Archive of Neurology, does not specify if the cells were stem cells derived from an early embryo or developed cells from an aborted child before the eight week stage. The cells are called embryonic nigral cells. Reuters said the 20 patients who received the implants had "small but definite" improvement in movement. The original article however does not go into detail about the amount of improvement and does not show that there was no subsequent deterioration.
Dr. John Shea, medical advisor to Campaign Life Coalition said this kind of ambiguity is a problem when laymen such as journalists attempt to evaluate scientific language. In an interview with LifeSiteNews.com, Dr. Shea said, "Nigral cells are those that are found in a part of the brain that produces dopamine. Well, of course, you can't get nigral cells out of a four day old embryo because there's no brain yet."
Dr. Shea, who read the article in detail, said that there were two problems with reporting on this as a major advance in Parkinson's research. "First is the confusion between foetal cells that are taken from aborted babies, and embryonic stem cells that are taken from early-stage embryos that are stored in IVF clinics and killed for the purpose. Nowhere does the article say that these are stem cells at all. The other problem is that there is little indication of significant, long-term improvement."
However, from the point of view of ethics, Dr. Shea pointed out that the difference is a small one. "Either the cells were taken from a child who had been aborted and had her tissues sold or donated to the researchers, or they had been taken from a child who had been created in a petri dish in the lab and killed specifically for the cells. Either way, the outcome is an incremental advance in what scientists know about Parkinson's at the cost of an undisclosed number of human lives."
Archives of Neurology:
http://archneur.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/full/61/6/858#REF-NOC40015-14
ph
Back to TopLatest Headlines
- BREAKING: US Congress Passes Health Care Reform Bill 220 to 215
- Stupak Amendment to Health Care Bill Passes 240 - 194 Saturday Evening
- Major Health Care Development - Pro-Life Stupak Amendment Vote OK'd for Today
- NY Times: Dems Banking on Later Squeezing Pro-Life Language Out of Bill in Committee
- USCCB Spokesman: "Definitely Not True" that Bishops Support Bill As it Stands
- TIME Got it Wrong - Prof. George Opposed Grandiose Kennedy Funeral
- USCCB Condemnation Tears Facade off "Phony" Abortion Compromise for Health Bill
- Health Care Bill Includes Monthly Abortion Premium: House Minority Leader Boehner
- TIME Article Setting Burke Against O'Malley Called "Tactical strike" on Behalf of Catholic Left
- Dirty Fighting on Abortion Funding: Word-Games and Health-Care Theatrics Boggle the Mind
- Commentary on November 6 News
- Note to LifeSiteNews Subscribers with Rogers email addresses
- New York Gov. Declares Nov. 10 Extraordinary Legislative Session for Same-Sex "Marriage"
- Washington's Pro-Family Amendment Effort Defeated - R-71 Almost Certain to Pass
- Vote Pushed Back on Canadian Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide Bill to Dec. 2
- Elderly U.K. Couple in Good Health Commit Suicide, Complain of Assisted Suicide Law
- Texas Late-Term Abortionist and Baptist Minister Admits: "Am I killing? Yes, I am"
- New Evidence Contradicts CCHD's Findings on Accused Pro-Abortion Partner
- Quebec Priest Denies Possibility of Sexual Reorientation Therapy on TV
- New Hampshire Same-Sex "Marriage" Law in Crosshairs after Maine's Law Crumbles
- Brooklyn Bishop Criticized for Recorded Message Praising Pro-Abortion Politician
- First Group of "Traditionalist" Anglicans in Britain Votes to Enter Catholic Church
Most Read this Week
- Planned Parenthood Director Resigns after Watching Ultrasound of Abortion Procedure
- Nun Defiant Following Rebuke, but Stops Abortion Escorting
- Breaking: Dominican Community Apologizes for Nun Caught Acting as Abortion Escort
- TIME Article Setting Burke Against O'Malley Called "Tactical strike" on Behalf of Catholics Left
- Over 200 Christendom College Students Protest Abortion at Planned Parenthood Clinic
- Scottish Gay Rights Activists Found Guilty of Pedophilia Sentenced to Life Imprisonment
- Newly Identified Corporate Supporters of Planned Parenthood Named
- US Congress Passes Health Care Reform Bill 218 to 215
- Major Health Care Bill Development - Stupak Hyde Amendment Vote OK'd
- Health Care Bill Includes Monthly Abortion Premium: House Minority Leader Boehner
MORE NEWS: 
LifeSiteNews.com Home Page Last 10 Days Archives Special Reports
Copyright © LifeSiteNews.com. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivatives License. You may republish this article or portions of it without request provided the content is not altered and it is clearly attributed to "LifeSiteNews.com". Any website publishing of complete or large portions of original LifeSiteNews articles MUST additionally include a live link to www.LifeSiteNews.com. The link is not required for excerpts. Republishing of articles on LifeSiteNews.com from other sources as noted is subject to the conditions of those sources.