Politics
Friday November 24, 2006
See today's LifeSiteNews stories
Critics Condemn UK Proposal to Legalize Northern Ireland Brothels
Say legalising brothels would only exacerbate trafficking in sex trade workers
By Gudrun Schultz
SOUTH BELFAST, Ireland, November 24, 2006 (LifeSiteNews.com) - A government proposal to legalise brothels in Northern Ireland has drawn strong condemnation from women’s organizations and political leaders, Ireland On-Line reported yesterday.
Leading the opposition was Ulster Unionist Assembly member Esmond Birnie, who issued a press release on the issue.
“South Belfast already has dozens of brothels operating at any particular time in rented apartments and this has not reduced problems in relation to kerb crawling in the area or indeed various immigration or trafficking abuses,” Dr. Birnie said.
“The government’s recent proposal to allow two or three prostitutes and/or receptionist or maid to work together legally in brothels is not a solution to the many problems associated with south Belfast's expanding vice industry.”
The government proposal to permit the establishment of legal brothels stated, ““At present only one person may work as a prostitute; more than that and the premises are classed as a brothel and are therefore illegal.
“This runs counter to the advice that women should not work alone in the interest of safety.
“The government (in England and Wales) plans to bring forward proposals for an amendment to the definition of a brothel so that two (or three) individuals may work together.
“We would propose to make similar amendment to the law in Northern Ireland.”
Mr Birnie said: “There is no evidence that decriminalisation or toleration of prostitution would achieve the objective of reducing exploitation, improving the safety of those involved and making resident communities safer.”
“The definition of prostitution as 'work' for women deeply threatens the rights and status of women everywhere. In the European Union, the Netherlands and Germany have already legalized the commodification and sale of women's bodies, with none of the social and economic benefits it was supposed to bring."
Further, he warned that legalized brothels would mean " no prohibition or restraint on advertising. Sex tourists will be able to book travel to South Belfast via the internet and make appointments to buy sex acts before they leave home."
As well, critics of the proposal say legalising brothels would only exacerbate trafficking in sex trade workers, allegedly an increasing problem in Northern Ireland.
A spokeswoman for Ruhama, an organization helping women involved in prostitution, told the IOL she would not support any legalisation of prostitution.
““Evidence has shown that in countries such as the Netherlands, where prostitution is legalised, it has not made it any safer for the women,” she said.
“While legalising prostitution can be proposed under the guise of helping the women involved, in reality it only enables the pimps to operate with legitimacy and impunity.”
Pimps have responded angrily to Catholic activists who were leafleting against legalization of prostitution. Gregory Carlin of the Irish Anti-Trafficking Agency was out distributing leaflets and was accosted last week.
To contact Mr. Birnie:
Dr Esmond Birnie MLA
Ulster Unionist Party
Northern Ireland Assembly
Parliament Buildings
Stormont,
Belfast
Northern Ireland
BT4 3XX
esmond.birnie@niassembly.gov.uk
Phone: 90873794 or 07703-184459
See related LifeSiteNews coverage:
Young Women Forced into Prostitution in the UK - More Evidence that Prostitution Leads to Sex Slavery
http://www.lifesitenews.com/ldn/2005/oct/05100304.html
Germany Rethinks Legalized Prostitution
http://www.lifesitenews.com/ldn/2005/may/05051301.html
Back to TopSHARE THIS STORY: E-mail Print Newsvine Digg Reddit Del.icio.us Facebook
Latest Headlines
- Human Rights Commission Drops Complaint Against Catholic Magazine
- Canada's Catholic Bishops United in Opposition to Order of Canada Being Awarded to Morgentaler
- Highlights from Canada's Debate on the Morgentaler Order of Canada Fiasco
- Golden Arches Awash in Rainbow Colors: Family Group Boycotts McDonalds for Support for Homosexual Agenda
- Bishops Investigate Report: 39 Abortions, 9684 Sterilizations Performed in Texas Catholic Hospitals
- President Bush and Senator McCain Address National Right to Life Conference
- Formal Request Filed to Terminate Morgentaler's Appointment to the Order of Canada
- UK Catholic, Muslim Doctors May be Forced to Refer for Abortion
- UK Contraception and Abortion Promoters calling for Sex Ed for Four Year-Olds
- LAPD Sued for Alleged Discrimination against Officer's Religious Beliefs
- Foremost Expert on Contraception Says the Pill is Not Working - It's "Outdated"
- Letters to the Editor for Friday, July 4
- Morgentaler Order of Canada Protest Set for July 9 in Ottawa
- LifeSiteNews Now on Facebook - Join Our Group, Spread the Word
Most Read this Week
- Archbishop Calls All Catholics to Demand National Award to Abortion Doc be Revoked
- Pro-Life Groups Horrified by Morgentaler's Appointment to the Order of Canada
- Pro-Life Group Appalled that Abortionist Morgentaler Would Even be Considered for Order of Canada
- Human Rights Commission Drops Complaint Against Catholic Magazine
- Online Polls Ask Whether Morgentaler Should Have Been Awarded Order of Canada
- Confirmed: Advisory Council Has Voted to Award Order of Canada to Abortionist Henry Morgentaler
- Numerous MPs Condemn Morgentaler Order of Canada Decision
- Order of Canada Members Return their Awards Over Morgentaler Decision
- Official Announcement of Arch-Abortionist Morgentaler Receiving Order of Canada
- National Group Launches Petition Calling for Morgentaler Order of Canada Appointment to be Revoked
MORE NEWS: 
LifeSiteNews.com Home Page Last 10 Days Archives Special Reports
Copyright © LifeSiteNews.com. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivatives License. You may republish this article without request provided the content is not altered and it is clearly attributed to "LifeSiteNews.com". Any Internet re-publishing of original LifeSiteNews articles MUST additionally include a live link to www.LifeSiteNews.com. Republishing of articles on LifeSiteNews that have come from other news sources as noted is subject to the conditions of those sources.