Politics
Friday November 2, 2007
Argentine Appeals Court Rules Against "Gay Marriage"
States that the law rightly favors "Unions that tend to continue the species"
TODAY'S HEADLINES
E-MAIL
PRINT
By Matthew Cullinan Hoffman
BUENOS AIRES, November 2, 2007 (LifeSiteNews.com) - A civil appeals court in Argentina has ruled against a homosexual couple asserting a "right" to marry each other, stating that "the standard that establishes that matrimony should be celebrated between people of different sexes has an absolutely objective and reasonable justification, which consists in the interest of the government in granting a privilege to unions that tend to continue the species."
The ruling, which was announced on October 31st, represents the second appeal struck down in an ongoing suit by the Argentine Federation of Lesbians, Gays, Bisexuals, and Transsexuals (FALGBT) on behalf of two homosexual couples, one of which consists of the artist Alejandro Vanelli and actor Ernesto Larrese. They are the first such cases in Argentine history.
The plaintiffs argue that Argentina's civil code, in particular articles 172 and 188, is "unconstitutional" because it is "discriminatory" and violates "equality under the law". Article 172 states that "The full and free consent expressed personally by a man and woman before the competent authority to celebrate it, is indispensable for the existence of marriage. The act that lacks any of these requirements will not produce civil effects..." Article 188 requires the couple to register as "husband and wife".
The plaintiffs also claim that Argentina is bound by international treaties to respect their "right of equality", which they argue translates to the "right" to "marry" someone of the same sex.
But Argentina's judiciary has consistently disagreed, basing itself on the very nature of human sexuality as a procreative act. They repeated this reasoning in their latest ruling. "Stable homosexual cohabitation corresponds, as a personal decision for each one, to an option that is carried out in the sphere of intimacy," wrote the judges of the Civil Chamber Court F. "But marriage transcends the sphere of intimacy. The refusal to consider unions between people of the same sex as matrimony exceeds an exclusively sexual perspective."
Civil court judge María Bacigalupo's initial ruling in one of the cases was even more scathing. "To affirm that the union of two homosexual persons should be considered matrimony, is to completely devalue the concept of the institution," she wrote. "Matrimony is and has been the institution that protects the heterosexual union from which will be born new members, children, so that society is not extinguished and so continues the course of life."
In the face of their latest defeat, FALGBT president Maria Rachid promised to continue the appeals process to the nation's Supreme Court. "We were expecting this to happen," she said. "There are very conservative judges, some of them have participated in the dictatorship (of the 1970s), and their thinking is very homophobic. But we trust in the Supreme Court, where we will elevate this petition for matrimony, because it is a right that the government owes us."
Related LifeSiteNews.com Coverage:
President-Elect of Argentina Defends Pro-Abortion Position and "Sexual Choice"
http://www.lifesite.net/ldn/2007/oct/07103001.html
Homosexual Activists Desecrate Catholic Church in Argentina
http://www.lifesite.net/ldn/2003/nov/03110605.html
ARGENTINA REGIONS RECOGNIZE HOMOSEXUAL UNIONS. BUENOS AIRES, March 18,
http://www.lifesite.net/ldn/2003/mar/03031808.html
Back to TopLatest Headlines
- Cardinal Rigali: You Can't Claim to be "Reducing Abortions" but Publicly Funding them in D.C.
- General Electric to Use Embryonic Stem Cells for Testing, Phase out Lab Rats
- Ohio Supreme Court Allows Planned Parenthood to Conceal Abortion Records in Sexual Abuse Case
- LifeSiteNews Canada Day and Independence Day Message. Taking a few days off. LSN returns Monday July 6
- Heroically Pro-Life Brazilian Archbishop's Resignation Accepted Under Cloud of Vatican Newspaper Misrepresentation
- Pro-Life Groups Announce New Colorado Personhood Initiative
- Judge Puts Kibosh on DC Gay "Marriage" Referendum
- Al Franken Win Hands Supermajority to Senate Democrats
- Group Funded by Canadian Bishops' D&P Joins with Others to Denounce the "Natural Family" and "Family Rights"
- Financially Troubled Planned Parenthood of El Paso Closes Doors
- Abortion Linked to Subsequent Pre-Term Births, New Research Again Confirms
- New Orleans Homosexual Couple Ask Fed. Court to Overturn Marriage Amendment
- Slim Hope Of New Ontario Progressive Conservative Party Leader Promoting Pro-Life, Pro-Family Issues
- Pope Accepts Resignation of Bishop Caught Involved in Homosexual Encounters
- Young Children Removed from UK Schools for "Inappropriate Sexual Behaviour"
- Northern Ireland Politician Cleared of Wrongdoing after Reiterating Christian Teaching on Homosexual Acts
- UK Conservative Leader Speaks at Gay Pride Fundraiser
- More Letters to the Editor on Canadian Catholic Development and Peace Scandal (July 1)
- Letters to the Editor - Readers Respond to Development and Peace Scandal
- Watch This Dramatic New Video on Catholic Bishops Conference Funding of Pro-Abortion Groups
Most Read this Week
- Pro-Lifer Attacked with SUV, Alleged Attacker Charged
- CCCB President on Websites Confronting D&P: “they’re not part of the church, they’re not Catholic”
- Huckabee Hashes Out Abortion Arguments with Comedian Jon Stewart
- Homosexual Duke U. Director Charged with Offering Adopted 5-Year-Old for Sex
- Amnesty International Caught in "One Big Lie"
- Editorial: Archbishop Weisgerber is Wrong - Vatican Stopped its Donation to UNICEF in 1996
- Pope: It is a Childish Faith to Oppose the Church Teaching on Life and Family
- Famed Fr. Corapi Calls Canadian Bishops' Dissent from Humanae Vitae "Catastrophic"
- Court Upholds VA Partial-Birth Abortion Ban
- Government of Trinidad and Tobago: No Homosexual "Weddings," No Abortion
MORE NEWS: 
LifeSiteNews.com Home Page Last 10 Days Archives Special Reports
Copyright © LifeSiteNews.com. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivatives License. You may republish this article or portions of it without request provided the content is not altered and it is clearly attributed to "LifeSiteNews.com". Any website publishing of complete or large portions of original LifeSiteNews articles MUST additionally include a live link to www.LifeSiteNews.com. The link is not required for excerpts. Republishing of articles on LifeSiteNews.com from other sources as noted is subject to the conditions of those sources.