Politics
Thursday May 8, 2008
North Carolina Appeals Court Upholds Joint Custody for Separated Lesbian Couple
Lesbian partner deemed de facto parent
TODAY'S HEADLINES
E-MAIL
PRINT
By Michael Baggot
RALEIGH, NC, May 8, 2008 (LifeSiteNews.com) - The North Carolina Court of Appeals upheld a district court decision on Tuesday granting a separated lesbian couple joint custody of the child they raised together.
Tuesday's decision upholds Durham County District Judge Ann McKown's ruling in Mason v. Dwinnell that biological parent Irene Dwinnell had freely created a de facto parent status for Joellen Mason, her domestic partner of eight years.
In 1997, Dwinnell gave birth to a child through artificial insemination. Mason was present during Dwinnell's pregnancy and helped raise the child. Although the hospital refused to recognize Mason as the child's second parent, the couple continued to identify each other as joint parents on school forms and other documents.
In 2000, the couple signed an agreement granting both equal parental rights. They separated a year later and began a custody routine that bounced the child back and forth between the two.
Following Dwinnell's efforts to decrease Mason's contact with the child, an October 2004 court granted the couple temporary joint legal and physical custody.
In June 2006, Judge McKown made the joint custody permanent on the grounds that Dwinnell had "encouraged, fostered, and facilitated the emotional and psychological bond between the minor child and Mason."
The Court of Appeals that upheld McKown's 2006 decision stated that it was treating Mason as it would any other "third party" who had acquired de facto parental status.
As Leonard notes, NC courts recognize that biological or adoptive parents have "paramount interest" in their child's care. Nonetheless, the state's courts have also used "the best interest of the child" to grant custody rights to de facto parents.
Tuesday's ruling is shaping legal precedence to give lesbian partners the same parental status granted to other third parties, such as stepparents of the opposite sex.
"Although this appeal arises in the context of a same-sex domestic partnership, it involves only the constitutional standards applicable to all custody disputes between legal parents and third parties," concluded Tuesday's ruling.
New York Law School Professor Arthur S. Leonard noted on his Leonard Link blog that the NC Court of Appeals "decided to treat this case as no different from any other case involving a custody dispute between a legal parent and a de facto parent."
Tuesday's decision contrasts with that of a similar 1991 case in New York, Alison D. v. Virginia M. In the 1991 decision, the New York Court of Appeals ruled that the lesbian partner of the child's biological parent was a "legal" stranger, despite having helped to raise the child.
Read Mason v. Dwinnell:
http://www.aoc.state.nc.us/www/public/coa/opinions/2008/070176-1.htm
Read Alison D. v. Virginia M.:
http://www.anusha.com/alison-d.htm
Back to TopLatest Headlines
- Cardinal Rigali: You Can't Claim to be "Reducing Abortions" but Publicly Funding them in D.C.
- General Electric to Use Embryonic Stem Cells for Testing, Phase out Lab Rats
- Ohio Supreme Court Allows Planned Parenthood to Conceal Abortion Records in Sexual Abuse Case
- LifeSiteNews Canada Day and Independence Day Message. Taking a few days off. LSN returns Monday July 6
- Heroically Pro-Life Brazilian Archbishop's Resignation Accepted Under Cloud of Vatican Newspaper Misrepresentation
- Pro-Life Groups Announce New Colorado Personhood Initiative
- Judge Puts Kibosh on DC Gay "Marriage" Referendum
- Al Franken Win Hands Supermajority to Senate Democrats
- Group Funded by Canadian Bishops' D&P Joins with Others to Denounce the "Natural Family" and "Family Rights"
- Financially Troubled Planned Parenthood of El Paso Closes Doors
- Abortion Linked to Subsequent Pre-Term Births, New Research Again Confirms
- New Orleans Homosexual Couple Ask Fed. Court to Overturn Marriage Amendment
- Slim Hope Of New Ontario Progressive Conservative Party Leader Promoting Pro-Life, Pro-Family Issues
- Pope Accepts Resignation of Bishop Caught Involved in Homosexual Encounters
- Young Children Removed from UK Schools for "Inappropriate Sexual Behaviour"
- Northern Ireland Politician Cleared of Wrongdoing after Reiterating Christian Teaching on Homosexual Acts
- UK Conservative Leader Speaks at Gay Pride Fundraiser
- More Letters to the Editor on Canadian Catholic Development and Peace Scandal (July 1)
- Letters to the Editor - Readers Respond to Development and Peace Scandal
- Watch This Dramatic New Video on Catholic Bishops Conference Funding of Pro-Abortion Groups
Most Read this Week
- Pro-Lifer Attacked with SUV, Alleged Attacker Charged
- CCCB President on Websites Confronting D&P: “they’re not part of the church, they’re not Catholic”
- Huckabee Hashes Out Abortion Arguments with Comedian Jon Stewart
- Homosexual Duke U. Director Charged with Offering Adopted 5-Year-Old for Sex
- Amnesty International Caught in "One Big Lie"
- Editorial: Archbishop Weisgerber is Wrong - Vatican Stopped its Donation to UNICEF in 1996
- Pope: It is a Childish Faith to Oppose the Church Teaching on Life and Family
- Famed Fr. Corapi Calls Canadian Bishops' Dissent from Humanae Vitae "Catastrophic"
- Court Upholds VA Partial-Birth Abortion Ban
- Government of Trinidad and Tobago: No Homosexual "Weddings," No Abortion
MORE NEWS: 
LifeSiteNews.com Home Page Last 10 Days Archives Special Reports
Copyright © LifeSiteNews.com. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivatives License. You may republish this article or portions of it without request provided the content is not altered and it is clearly attributed to "LifeSiteNews.com". Any website publishing of complete or large portions of original LifeSiteNews articles MUST additionally include a live link to www.LifeSiteNews.com. The link is not required for excerpts. Republishing of articles on LifeSiteNews.com from other sources as noted is subject to the conditions of those sources.