Politics
Friday September 5, 2008
BC Court Ruling Means only Pro-Abortion Information is Allowed Inside Bubble Zones
TODAY'S HEADLINES
E-MAIL
PRINT
By Hilary White
VANCOUVER, September 5, 2008 (LifeSiteNews.com) - In December 1998 Gordon Watson and Don Spratt were arrested for having stood inside a "bubble zone" in front of Everywoman's abortion site in Vancouver. Today, the British Columbia Court of Appeal agreed with a previous court and ruled that the so-called "bubble zones" surrounding abortion facilities in BC do not violate the freedom of speech guarantees enshrined in the Charter of Rights.
Although the courts found that prohibitions in the Access to Abortion Services Act on protesting in front of abortion facilities were in violation of the Charter, neither court was willing to overturn those provisions. Instead, they relied on Section 1 of the Charter to uphold the bubble zone, citing it as a "reasonable limitation on the freedom of expression" because of its importance in protecting medical clinics, personnel, and patients. The Court of Appeal was unwilling to restrict the application of the Act to violent and threatening behaviour, claiming a "bright line rule" was essential to enforcement, clarity, and protection.
The two men were charged with violating BC's Access to Abortion Services Act that prohibits pro-life sidewalk counsellors or protesters from coming within 50 metres of an abortion facility. They were holding a wooden cross and signs that said "Abortion is Murder" and "Unborn Persons have a right to live."
A number of interveners in the case argued that the bubble zone law is a violation of constitutionally protected rights of freedom of expression. Interveners included the BC Civil Liberties Association, Canadian Nurses for Life and a coalition of religious groups including the Catholic Civil Rights League and the Evangelical Fellowship of Canada.
The Catholic Civil Rights League today said that the ruling meant, "In effect, within the bubble zones, there would only be allowed a one-sided information zone, limited to abortion providers."
Joanne McGarry said that the law, as it is now interpreted by the courts, "likely makes it an offence for medical information of any kind to be provided within the subject zones, unless it is provided by the abortion provider."
"The Court of Appeal" she said, "has effectively ruled that these bubble zones are to be limited to pro-abortion activities. Presumably the court believes women in B.C. cannot be exposed even to the peaceful presentation of other choices, even if based on a growing recognition of negative post-abortion medical consequences."
The appellants have not as yet announced whether they will seek to appeal the decision to the Supreme Court of Canada.
Read related LifeSiteNews.com coverage:
BC Pro-life Advocates Testing the Limits of Bubble Zones
http://www.lifesitenews.com/ldn/2006/may/06050505.html
Back to TopLatest Headlines
- US Congress Passes Health Care Reform Bill 220 - 215
- Stupak Amendment to Health Care Bill Passes 240 - 194 Saturday Evening
- NY Times: Dems Banking on Later Squeezing Pro-Life Language Out of Bill in Committee
- USCCB Spokesman: "Definitely Not True" that Bishops Support Bill As it Stands
- TIME Got it Wrong - Prof. George Opposed Grandiose Kennedy Funeral
- Major Health Care Development - Pro-Life Stupak Amendment Vote OK'd for Saturday
- USCCB Condemnation Tears Facade off "Phony" Abortion Compromise for Health Bill
- Health Care Bill Includes Monthly Abortion Premium: House Minority Leader Boehner
- TIME Article Setting Burke Against O'Malley Called "Tactical strike" on Behalf of Catholic Left
- Dirty Fighting on Abortion Funding: Word-Games and Health-Care Theatrics Boggle the Mind
- Commentary on November 6 News
- Note to LifeSiteNews Subscribers with Rogers email addresses
- New York Gov. Declares Nov. 10 Extraordinary Legislative Session for Same-Sex "Marriage"
- Washington's Pro-Family Amendment Effort Defeated - R-71 Almost Certain to Pass
- Vote Pushed Back on Canadian Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide Bill to Dec. 2
- Elderly U.K. Couple in Good Health Commit Suicide, Complain of Assisted Suicide Law
- Texas Late-Term Abortionist and Baptist Minister Admits: "Am I killing? Yes, I am"
- New Evidence Contradicts CCHD's Findings on Accused Pro-Abortion Partner
- Quebec Priest Denies Possibility of Sexual Reorientation Therapy on TV
- New Hampshire Same-Sex "Marriage" Law in Crosshairs after Maine's Law Crumbles
- Brooklyn Bishop Criticized for Recorded Message Praising Pro-Abortion Politician
- First Group of "Traditionalist" Anglicans in Britain Votes to Enter Catholic Church
Most Read this Week
- Planned Parenthood Director Resigns after Watching Ultrasound of Abortion Procedure
- Nun Defiant Following Rebuke, but Stops Abortion Escorting
- Breaking: Dominican Community Apologizes for Nun Caught Acting as Abortion Escort
- TIME Article Setting Burke Against O'Malley Called "Tactical strike" on Behalf of Catholics Left
- Over 200 Christendom College Students Protest Abortion at Planned Parenthood Clinic
- US Congress Passes Health Care Reform Bill 218 to 215
- Newly Identified Corporate Supporters of Planned Parenthood Named
- Scottish Gay Rights Activists Found Guilty of Pedophilia Sentenced to Life Imprisonment
- Major Health Care Bill Development - Stupak Hyde Amendment Vote OK'd
- Health Care Bill Includes Monthly Abortion Premium: House Minority Leader Boehner
MORE NEWS: 
LifeSiteNews.com Home Page Last 10 Days Archives Special Reports
Copyright © LifeSiteNews.com. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivatives License. You may republish this article or portions of it without request provided the content is not altered and it is clearly attributed to "LifeSiteNews.com". Any website publishing of complete or large portions of original LifeSiteNews articles MUST additionally include a live link to www.LifeSiteNews.com. The link is not required for excerpts. Republishing of articles on LifeSiteNews.com from other sources as noted is subject to the conditions of those sources.