Commentary by Alex Schadenberg, Executive Director, Euthanasia Prevention Coalition
March 3, 2009 (LifeSiteNews.com) - The 2008 Summary of Oregon’s Death with Dignity Act (DWDA) was released on March 3, 2009.
The report stated that: "During 2008, 88 prescriptions for lethal medications were written under the provisions of the DWDA compared to 85 during 2007 (and 65 during 2006). Of these, 54 patients took the (lethal) medications, 22 died of their underlying disease, and 12 were alive at the end of 2008.
"In addition, 6 people with earlier prescriptions died from taking the (lethal) medications, resulting in a total of 60 DWDA deaths during 2008, which was up from 49 DWDA deaths during 2007 and 46 DWDA deaths during 2006. This corresponds to an estimated 19.4 DWDA deaths per 10,000 total deaths, up from an estimated 14.7 DWDA deaths per 10,000 total death in 2006."
There has, therefore, been an increase by 30% in the total estimated DWDA deaths in two years, between 2006 and 2008.
The report also stated that:
- 59 physicians wrote 88 prescriptions for lethal drugs.
- Since the law was passed in 1997, 401 people have died under the terms of the law.
- The stated reason for wanting suicide assistance were - 95% loss of autonomy, 92% decreasing ability to participate in activities, 92% loss of dignity, 5% (3 people) inadequate pain control.
- 2 referrals were made to the Oregon Medical Board for incorrectly completed reporting forms. The Oregon Medical Board found no violations of "good faith compliance" with the act and did not sanction any physicians for "unprofessional conduct" regarding the Act.
- 2 people were referred for a psychiatric evaluation, up from none last year.
The annual report continues to lack the essential information for determining the social context of these decisions. The reporting system also continues to lack any safeguards for the people who die by assisted suicide, based on the fact that reporting is completed by the physician who prescribes the lethal drugs, while the physician was only present at the time of ingesting the lethal drugs 11 times, or 18.3% of the time.
Further, there are no third party reports or investigations to ensure that the cases fulfilled the requirements of the law and/or that the reports are accurately reported, and there are no investigations to confirm that reports were submitted for all assisted suicide deaths.
In other words, we do not know whether other assisted suicide deaths occurred and we do not know if any of the people who died by assisted suicide were socially pressured or died outside of the guidelines of the law. This is because the Oregon Death with Dignity Act relies on physicians to submit reports based on their own actions. It is unlikely that any physician will ever submit a report that admits to decisions or actions that are outside of the legal parameters.
Even though concerns about inadequate pain control are the reason that most people support legalizing assisted suicide, only 3 of the 60 people who died by assisted suicide in Oregon last year listed concerns about inadequate pain control as a reason for them to request assisted suicide.
The 2008 report, like the previous reports, lacks the necessary information to assure the public that all is well in Oregon.
As the Oregonian Editorial Board stated on September 2008 in their article, "Washington state’s assisted suicide measure: Don’t go there": "Oregon’s physician-assisted suicide program has not been sufficiently transparent. Essentially, a coterie of insiders run the program, with a handful of doctors and others deciding what the public may know. We’re aware of no substantiated abuses, but we’d feel more confident with more sunlight on the program." (http://www.oregonlive.com/opinion/index.ssf/2008/09/washington_states_assistedsuic.html)