Executive summary
- On November 3, 2026, eight people, five of whom never took the oath of office before the President of the Republic, met at a “General Assembly of Judges of the Constitutional Tribunal” convened by Anna Korwin-Piotrowska. As we pointed out on Monday, a meeting convened by an unauthorized person and in breach of procedure could not produce any legal effects.
- Just as we predicted, the “General Assembly” failed to reach a quorum. Those present “calculated” it on the basis of twelve judges, leaving out the president, the vice-president and one other judge, although the statute requires two-thirds of the total number of judges of the Tribunal – a number the Constitution sets at fifteen.
- Any disciplinary action against the President of the Constitutional Tribunal and his deputy is null and void. Not only were the disciplinary benches drawn unlawfully, but in both of them a majority are unauthorized persons. Moreover, the charges themselves are unfounded, as in essence they concern lawful conduct.
(Rule of Law Observer) — On Friday, October 30, 2026, police subordinate to Donald Tusk’s government took control of the entrance to Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal (CT). The running of the Tribunal was taken over by Anna Korwin-Piotrowska – a person who never took the oath of office before the President of the Republic and therefore never entered into a service relationship with the CT. She unlawfully “suspended” the Tribunal’s president, Bogdan Święczkowski, and its vice-president, Bartłomiej Sochański, barring them from the building – a ban the police are enforcing. She then convened the CT’s General Assembly of Judges, announcing her intention of having both of them removed from office through disciplinary proceedings.
That meeting took place on November 3, 2026, at the Tribunal’s seat. Eight people attended: Magdalena Bentkowska, Dariusz Szostek and Sławomir Patyra, who took the oath before the President of the Republic, and Krystian Markiewicz, Maciej Taborowski, Marcin Dziurda, Maciej Berek and Anna Korwin-Piotrowska herself – five people who never took such an oath. Those present adopted the Tribunal’s draft budget for 2027, declared that the quorum was eight, and drew by lot the disciplinary courts and disciplinary officers in the cases of President Święczkowski and Vice-President Sochański.
It must be stressed at the outset that, as we pointed out on Monday in our legal opinion, the “General Assembly” was void from the moment it was convened. It was convened by a person who is not a CT judge and therefore, all the more so, cannot stand in for the President of the Tribunal. She did so in breach of the statutory notice requirements and admitted persons who are not members of the Assembly. Tuesday’s proceedings only add further arguments.
A quorum ‘calculated’ from 12 judges has no basis in the law
Since all seven lawful judges elected to the CT during the two previous terms of the Sejm (Poland’s lower house of parliament) had announced that they would not attend, we predicted that the Assembly would lack a quorum – and so it did. Under Article 8(1) of the Act on the Organization of the Constitutional Tribunal and the Mode of Proceedings Before the Constitutional Tribunal (hereinafter: the CT Proceedings Act):
The General Assembly shall adopt resolutions by an absolute majority vote, in the presence of at least two-thirds of the total number of the judges of the Tribunal, unless a relevant statute provides otherwise.
The total number of judges is set unambiguously by Article 194(1) of the Constitution:
The Constitutional Tribunal shall be composed of 15 judges chosen individually by the Sejm for a term of office of 9 years from amongst persons distinguished by their knowledge of the law.
Two-thirds of 15 is 10. Yet only eight people attended, and – as we have repeatedly pointed out – only three of them are CT judges. The other five never took the oath before the president, and only that oath establishes a judge’s service relationship with the Tribunal (Articles 4(1) and 5 of the Act on the Status of the Judges of the Constitutional Tribunal, hereinafter: the Status Act). Moreover, as we have also stressed many times, Article 6(1) of the CT Proceedings Act provides:
The General Assembly shall comprise the incumbent judges of the Tribunal who have taken the oath of office before the President of the Republic of Poland.
But even if all eight were (unlawfully) treated as CT judges, eight is still two short of 10. Aware of this, the participants adopted a peculiar interpretation under which two-thirds is calculated not from 15, but from the 12 judges “obliged to attend” – leaving out the “suspended” president and vice-president, as well as Judge Jarosław Wyrembak, whom they labeled a so-called “stand-in” judge. Such a calculation is wholly inadmissible: the statute refers to the total number of judges of the Tribunal, not to the number of judges able or willing to attend at any given moment.
Nor does Judge Wyrembak’s case change anything. The dispute over his seat goes back to 2015, when the outgoing Sejm, controlled by a majority led by Civic Platform (PO), elected five judges “in advance” – two of them in clear breach of the Constitution – and, after the elections, the new Law and Justice (PiS) majority elected all five anew (we have written more about this dispute here). Yet even if one accepted that his election was flawed, the proper remedy would be for the Sejm to elect a new person to the seat – not to “subtract” him from the total. Vacancies have never lowered the quorum. On the contrary, when President Karol Nawrocki swore in Magdalena Bentkowska and Dariusz Szostek on April 1, 2026, his office justified this precisely by the need to meet the statutory requirement for the Tribunal to sit as a full bench. Statutory thresholds are absolute: missing judges do not lower them – they simply prevent the body from acting until the vacancies are filled. The participants themselves know this well: on July 14, 2026, Magdalena Bentkowska and Dariusz Szostek walked out of an assembly on the budget convened by the CT president, thereby breaking its quorum.
Were the “Assembly’s” logic to be accepted, the Sejm could manipulate the quorum simply by leaving vacancies unfilled – which is, in a sense, exactly what happened in recent years, when the ruling majority failed for more than a year to elect judges to vacant seats. Yet in its judgment of December 3, 2015 (ref. K 34/15), the Tribunal stated plainly:
A temporary vacancy in the composition of the Tribunal is also constitutionally acceptable, provided, however, that it results from a combination of justified factual circumstances and not from a strategy or means of action adopted by a state body.
The ‘suspension’ of the president and vice-president does not change the total number of judges
Leaving out the president and vice-president is equally inadmissible – if not more so. Quite apart from the fact that – as we showed in detail in our legal opinion – the break in official duties provided for in Article 130 of the Law on the System of Common Courts does not apply to CT judges at all, even if it did, it would have no bearing on how many judges the Tribunal has. A “suspended” judge remains a judge, and the total number of judges remains the one laid down in the Constitution.
This interpretation has been sharply criticized by a wide range of lawyers, including those who never supported the previous government’s position in the dispute over the Tribunal. Indeed, this logic would allow the President of the Tribunal – or a person claiming to stand in for him – to shape the quorum at will by “suspending” inconvenient judges one after another.
This is not merely a theoretical scenario. As we have reported, Minister of Justice Adam Bodnar reshaped court boards in a similar way – by suspending lower-court presidents before seeking the boards’ opinions on dismissing their superiors. In its judgment of October 16, 2024 (ref. K 2/24), the Constitutional Tribunal held this suspension mechanism to be unconstitutional.
READ: New ‘judges’ acting as Poland’s constitutional tribunal ‘invalid’: lawyer
Draw of disciplinary benches – void, and the charges unfounded
The draws of the disciplinary courts and disciplinary officers are void not only because the Assembly itself was void, but also because they do not fall within its powers at all. Article 25(2) of the Status Act leaves no doubt:
The composition of adjudicating benches shall be selected by a draw carried out by the President of the Tribunal.
Likewise, under Article 27(1), it is the President of the Tribunal who “shall carry out a draw to select a judge of the Tribunal to act as a disciplinary officer.” The draws conducted by Anna Korwin-Piotrowska are therefore void. In the CT president’s own case – given the obvious conflict of interest – these steps could at most be taken by the vice-president as his deputy (although the statute does not say so expressly); in the vice-president’s case, only by the president.
Moreover, in both benches drawn, a majority are unauthorized persons. The case of President Święczkowski is to be heard by Magdalena Bentkowska, Krystian Markiewicz and Maciej Taborowski, and that of Vice-President Sochański by Maciej Berek, Anna Korwin-Piotrowska and Rafał Wojciechowski. In each bench, two of the three members never took the oath before the president, so any ruling they issue will be void. Poland’s Supreme Court has recently pointed to similar defects – disciplinary courts sitting with members who had not been validly appointed – in cases involving judges assigned by the Minister of Justice.
The composition of these “courts” also blatantly violates the principle nemo iudex in causa sua. One of the charges against the president is that he refused to allow those who took the “oath” in the Sejm to adjudicate – and his case is to be heard by Krystian Markiewicz and Maciej Taborowski. In the vice-president’s case, the bench includes Anna Korwin-Piotrowska herself, who had earlier “suspended” him by her own order. Even if these persons had been properly drawn and were CT judges (which, as shown above, they are not), they would have to recuse themselves (Article 40 § 1(1) and Article 41 § 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, applicable under Article 30 of the Status Act).
The charges themselves are entirely unfounded. First, the President is accused of failing to convene an assembly on the budget – yet he did convene them, and the July session failed only because Magdalena Bentkowska and Dariusz Szostek walked out. Second, refusing to let persons who never took the oath before the president adjudicate is not misconduct but a duty imposed directly by statute. Third, the interim measure of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) – as we have already explained – is addressed to the state, not to the president of the CT, and cannot override a statute in force; moreover, as the Constitutional Tribunal held in its judgment of March 10, 2022 (ref. K 7/21), the ECtHR has no jurisdiction to assess the lawfulness of the election of CT judges. Finally, the charge of “political” statements does not identify any specific statement, while defending the Tribunal against an unlawful takeover is one of its president’s basic duties.
READ: Globalist Polish prime minister attempts coup as police seize tribunal
In the president’s case, fate was unkind to the ruling majority’s appointees
Perhaps the greatest irony of all is that the disciplinary officer drawn in the CT president’s case was Judge Stanisław Piotrowicz, a former Law and Justice (PiS) MP elected to the Tribunal by the previous parliamentary majority. Setting aside all the defects described above, the chances of the outcome hoped for by the current government’s appointees are therefore slim. Under Article 27 of the Status Act, it is the disciplinary officer who decides whether to open proceedings and files the application with the disciplinary court. A refusal may be appealed, and if the disciplinary court sets it aside, its recommendations are binding on the officer – but the Status Act provides no means of enforcing them or of replacing the officer’s application with one filed by anyone else.
Given that the disciplinary court was designated by an unauthorized person and is dominated by unauthorized persons, Judge Piotrowicz may be expected – in line with the law – not to act at all in such deeply flawed “proceedings.” Disciplinary proceedings against him would, in turn, again require a draw by the president of the CT; another draw by Anna Korwin-Piotrowska would be just as void.
Summary
Tuesday’s “General Assembly” confirmed everything we wrote on Monday. It was convened by an unauthorized person in breach of procedure, attended by persons who are not CT judges, and its quorum was “calculated” contrary to the statute and the Constitution. All resolutions adopted and all draws conducted at the meeting are void and have no legal effect.
Under the law, the President and Vice-President of the Constitutional Tribunal can therefore rest easy: any ruling of a “disciplinary court” against them would be void – issued by an improperly designated bench with unauthorized members, without any factual basis and possibly even without an application from the disciplinary officer.
Unfortunately, the events since Friday show that Donald Tusk’s government has stopped respecting the law altogether, and it cannot be ruled out that it will use the rulings of these “disciplinary courts” to try, for instance, to arrest the president of the CT and his deputy. If that happens, one can be certain that once the current government falls, its members will be held accountable, and the functions unlawfully taken from the president and vice-president will be restored to them.
(This article was first published on the English-language page of Obserwator Praworzadności, “Rule of Law Observer.” Republished with permission.)
