Featured Image

May 11, 2021 (LifeSiteNews) — At some point during the three days I watched the pre-recorded online 2021 Vatican Health Conference, I noticed the product placement.

Some of it was rather innocent, really. While looking at the décor of the homes or offices behind the participants, I began to notice the carefully placed books for sale. One was fetchingly propped up on a piano. The funny thing is that even though I knew that the guests of the Pontifical Council for Culture were angling for a sly sale, I went ahead and bought a book anyway. Well played, Dr. William Li, President, Medical Director, and CEO of the Angiogenesis Foundation. Well played.

Some of product placement was not very funny, however. The emblem of the Pontifical Council for Culture was constantly on the screen, and so it looked like a Vatican stamp of approval of everyone who spoke and of everything they said. I was rather startled on the third day when an American theology professor from Scotland’s St Andrews University said that “we can forgive people for believing in a soul,” and an American psychology professor at Yale suggested that while kids have imaginary friends, adults have God.

Now to be honest, this was top level “philosophy of the mind” stuff and a serious mental workout for a PhD drop-out like myself, but given that the Vatican was hosting this conversation, it would have been nice if they had offered a robust response by a star of Catholic philosophy like Peter Kreeft. I get that, in the closing words of conference co-host Dr. Robin Smith, the “Vatican Conference focuses on collaboration, putting differences aside, and working together to solve problems and improve human health.” However, I didn’t see a whole lot of Catholic contribution to the collaboration. Even in something as innocuous as the round-table between representatives of different religions about food, we heard from Islam, Judaism, and Mormonism (no coffee!?), but nothing about Catholic (or even Orthodox) penitential practices in Lent.

That said, Msgr. Tomasz Trafny, the Polish head of the science and faith department of the Pontifical Council for Culture, put up a polite fight against introducing “irreversible changes” to the human genome during Friday’s alarmingly entitled “Human Enhancement Round Table.” On the other hand, there wasn’t a lot of push-back when the Harvard Professor of Genetics brushed aside the ideas of “natural” and “unnatural” or even a giggle when he said that “safety is the purview of the Food and Drug Administration.”

Yes, Harvard. From a strictly worldly point of view, there was an impressive line-up of participants at the Vatican health conference: American professors from Ivy League schools; international CEOs from Big Pharma; billionaires like Judy Faulkner of Epic Systems; famous soprano Renee Fleming talking about music therapy; NFL star Brandon Marshall on mental illness; supermodel Cindy Crawford on being as nice to yourself as you are to your best friend. There were also celebrated journalists and TV personalities giving masterclasses in softball interviews: Katie Couric, ABC’s Robin Roberts, CNN’s Sanjay Gupta, ABC’s Anna Robach, Oprah’s Amos Oz. There was even royalty in the person of the Knights of Malta’s Dominique Prince de La Rochefoucald-Montbel, Jordan’s anti-cancer activist Princess Dina Mired, and Aerosmith’s Joe Perry.

There were a few remarks from Cardinal Ravasi, an address by Cardinal Parolin and, at the end, a speech by Pope Francis. Theirs were the biggest names representing Catholicism — and the Italian language. For an international gathering, the Fifth Vatican Conference was overwhelmingly American and anglophone. For a Vatican conference, it was strangely secular.

From a viewer’s perspective, it was also a firehose of information and opinion. There were dozens of presentations on a myriad of topics, including mRNA vaccines and gene editing, and although these were usually short, they were sometimes complex. They were rapid fire, one after other without a recess, and on Friday, I had to finally take a break in order to report that Chelsea Clinton had called for global regulation of social media so that criticism of COVID-19 vaccines could be suppressed. On Saturday I was back at the screen to see if primatologist Jane Goodall would make my next headline by saying humans are basically just chimpanzees. In fact, she said we were the “fifth great ape” and acknowledged that we are genetically “just over 1%” different from chimpanzees—and much more intelligent,” if lacking in wisdom. She hopes we will extend the Golden Rule to animals and stop trashing the planet.

Given the diversity of the topics and speakers — Cindy Crawford on food, researchers on the ethics of collecting our private medical data for the greater good of humanity — I often wondered who all this expensive intellectual largess was for. As it happens, it was for university students, particularly those associated with the Vatican’s Science and Faith (STOQ) Foundation, including those at the pontifical universities in Rome, like the Angelicum, Gregoriana, Salesianum, Urbaniana, the Laterna university, or Santa Croce. If any of them are reading this, I hope they will write in to tell me what they made of it all. Incidentally, if anyone mentioned the Holy Name of Jesus during the Vatican conference, I must have been working on my Chelsea Clinton story, for I never heard it uttered.

— Article continues below Petition —
PETITION: Support Archbishop Naumann's defense of LIFE as head of Bishops' Pro-Life Committee
  Show Petition Text
25879 have signed the petition.
Let's get to 30000!
Thank you for signing this petition!
Add your signature:
  Show Petition Text
Keep me updated via email on this petition and related issues.
Keep me updated via email on this petition and related issues.

The head of the U.S. Bishops' Pro-Life office, Archbishop Joseph Naumann, is under attack for consistently calling out Joe Biden for the serious sin of publicly promoting abortion.

A petition has been launched against Archbishop Naumann because he continues to preach the truth that "Catholic" politicians who promote abortion are endangering their souls and causing grave scandal to the faithful.

We must now come to Archbishop Naumann's defense.

Please SIGN and SHARE WIDELY this petition which urges the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops not to demote or remove Archbishop Naumann from head of the Pro-Life Committee, but rather, to follow his lead in urging Joe Biden to repent of the terrible sin of promoting the murder the unborn human beings.

Archbishop Naumann has come under fire, from people who plainly know or care little about Catholic moral teaching, for stating the obvious in a recent interview with LifeSiteNews:

It is the responsibility of the Bishops of the United States to defend the most fundamental of all human rights, the right to life, and to protect the integrity of Catholic moral teaching. We cannot abdicate either of these responsibilities, even as we are eager to work with everyone to promote the common good...

We must continue to speak to President Biden, as well as all Catholics, and even all Americans, about the truth of what abortion is. Abortion is not something to be celebrated, and it is not healthcare. It is the intentional killing of a child. To participate in abortion or to promote abortion is a grave evil.

And, in an even more pointed statement made in an interview with Catholic World Report, Archbishop Naumann defended the Holy Eucharist against Biden's attack on human life, suggesting that Biden should not present himself for Holy Communion:

When Catholics receive the Eucharist, they are acknowledging the Real Presence of Jesus, and also belief in the teachings of the Church. President Biden doesn’t believe in the Church’s teachings on the Sanctity of Human Life, and he should not put the priest in the situation where he has to decide whether or not to allow him to receive the Eucharist. He should know that after 78 years as a Catholic.

But, again, by calling out Joe Biden for his public promotion of abortion, Archbishop Naumann is not doing anything out-of-the-ordinary.

He is only saying what the bishops should have all been saying, with a unified voice, since Biden won the nomination during the election campaign.

Indeed, in an open letter published on inauguration day, Archbishop José Gomez, president of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB), warned that Biden’s pledge to pursue anti-life and anti-family policies would advance “moral evils” in the areas of “abortion, contraception, marriage, and gender."

Please SIGN and SHARE this petition to the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops not to demote or replace Archbishop Naumann as head of the Pro-Life Committee, but rather, to follow his lead in urging Joe Biden to repent of the horrific sin of promoting the murder of the preborn.


'EXCLUSIVE: Bishop Naumann – US bishops must address scandal of ‘Catholic’ Biden championing abortion' -

'Bishops need to ‘correct’ pro-abortion Biden for ‘acting contrary’ to Catholic faith: Abp. Naumann' -

  Hide Petition Text

Meanwhile, it didn’t escape my notice that some of the companies that funded the conference also provided presentations. The Church of Latter-day Saints, whose baptisms the Catholic Church does not accept as valid, provided money, an Elder to offer the Mormon point of view in interreligious round tables, another Elder to discuss medical missionary work (very well, as it happens), and a Utah gazillionaire to discuss effective philanthropy. The latter, I feel compelled to add, was the only speaker I saw who had religious art in the background: a tasteful representation of the Lord Jesus Christ. (Pope Francis was framed by rather tacky white wallpaper.) Moderna supplied even more money than the Church of Latter-day Saints, and its CEO told us the story and workings of the abortion-tainted Moderna mRA COVID-19 vaccination. The Vatican announced that it had given him an award.

Little wonder, then, that I felt very often that the presentations were selling stuff: not just books about compassion, longevity and food-as-medicine, but the latest biotechnology, the latest telehealth software, the voluntary surrender of privacy for swifter, more effective medical treatment, COVID-19 vaccines. Although many of the projects and products discussed are undoubtedly beneficial to humanity, the crossed keys of St. Peter in the corner of the screen came to resemble the Royal Warrant or the three feathers of the Prince of Wales stamped on various British businesses, like Burberry's fashion house or Taylor’s of Harrogate (“specialists in tea and coffee”).

Featured Image

Dorothy Cummings McLean is a Canadian journalist, essayist, and novelist. She earned an M.A. in English Literature from the University of Toronto and an M.Div./S.T.B. from Toronto’s Regis College. She was a columnist for the Toronto Catholic Register for nine years and has contributed to Catholic World Report. Her first book, Seraphic Singles,  was published by Novalis (2010) in Canada, Liguori in the USA, and Homo Dei in Poland. Her second, Ceremony of Innocence, was published by Ignatius Press (2013). Dorothy lives near Edinburgh, Scotland with her husband.


Commenting Guidelines
LifeSiteNews welcomes thoughtful, respectful comments that add useful information or insights. Demeaning, hostile or propagandistic comments, and streams not related to the storyline, will be removed.

LSN commenting is not for frequent personal blogging, on-going debates or theological or other disputes between commenters.

Multiple comments from one person under a story are discouraged (suggested maximum of three). Capitalized sentences or comments will be removed (Internet shouting).

LifeSiteNews gives priority to pro-life, pro-family commenters and reserves the right to edit or remove comments.

Comments under LifeSiteNews stories do not necessarily represent the views of LifeSiteNews.