News
Featured Image

(LifeSiteNews) – A new collection of remarks by U.S. Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito highlights the conservative jurist’s conviction that the forced redefinition of marriage to include same-sex couples marked “perhaps the decisive point in our nation’s turn against religious liberty.”

This month saw the publication of So Ordered, which articulates Alito’s judicial philosophy through various speeches he delivered over the course of his career, organized by topic. ABC News noted that among the subjects is 2015’s fateful Obergefell v. Hodges ruling in which the nation’s highest court forced all 50 states to recognize homosexual unions as marriages. Alito was among the dissenters.

The justice, a Catholic appointed by former President George W. Bush, has discussed the case various times in the past as captured in the book, including a 2018 speech explaining that he “expressed my worry that equating the expression of certain views with bigotry — or, if you like, with dignitary harm — would drive believers out of public life.”

The book also includes a previously unpublished speech, delivered to the Catholic nonprofit Magnificat Foundation in 2022, in which Alito argues his fears have since been vindicated.

“Quite suddenly, religious liberty has become controversial,” he said, citing various cases over the years concerning attempts to force private businesses to serve same-sex “weddings” or faith-based organizations were denied religious exemptions to health and employment mandates pertaining to homosexuality. “What we see in these and other cases is a refusal to live in peace with those who violate the new moral code.”

In another of the book’s newly published speeches, to Thomas Aquinas College in 2021, Alito noted that Americans opposed to same-sex “marriage” found themselves “so beaten down that they were ‘a people who shunned the light of day.’ They were ‘found in corners, and alleys, and cellars, and the housetops, or in the recesses of the country.’” Perhaps relatedly, Alito has also said he thinks overturning Obergefell is unlikely.

ABC stressed that the religious parties ultimately prevailed in “nearly all” of the cases Alito cites, but that has not slowed persistence of such challenges. Colorado baker Jack Phillips, for instance, won a 2018 Supreme Court case over his right to refuse to create homosexual “wedding” cakes, yet was dragged back to court years later over demands to create a “transgender” cake.

Undoing Obergefell has long been a goal of social conservatives and constitutional textualists and originalists but remains an uphill battle. 

Three of the current sitting justices — Alito, Chief Justice John Roberts, and conservatives Justice Clarence Thomas — dissented from Obergefell. Thomas and Alito are considered reliable votes to overturn if the chance arises, given statements both have made in the years since. But it is less certain how Roberts and the Court’s three more recent Republican appointees would rule, given past statements about deferring to precedent and their mixed records on cases important to conservatives. In November 2025, the Court declined to hear a case from former Kentucky county clerk Kim Davis that could have reconsidered Obergefell.

Further, as a practical matter, even if the Supreme Court reversed Obergefell, recognition of same-sex “marriage” would still be mandatory nationwide, thanks to former President Joe Biden signing the so-called Respect for Marriage Act, which codified Obergefell, in 2023. Thirty-two states still have duly enacted same-sex “marriage” bans on the books, according to World Population Review, all of which have been blocked from enforcement since Obergefell. Only 18 states plus the District of Columbia have no ban in place.

At least half a dozen states have adopted resolutions urging the nation’s highest court to revere Obergefell. They have no legal force or can they begin any legal battle that could eventually put the issue back before the nation’s highest court, but they raise awareness of an issue that, while long since declared “settled” by the establishments of both parties, set the stage for today’s battles over transgenderism, surrogacy, and religious freedom.

18 Comments

  1. Loading...