WASHINGTON, D.C. (LifeSiteNews) – Conservative U.S. Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito says he has an idea of who leaked an early draft of his majority opinion overturning Roe v. Wade, but the evidence is not conclusive enough to name a suspect publicly.
On June 24, 2022, the nation’s highest court issued its ruling in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, not only upholding a 15-week abortion ban in Mississippi but also overturning Roe, which for half a century had forbidden states from directly banning most abortions.
Writing for the 5-4 majority to overturn Roe, Alito declared Roe “egregiously wrong from the start,” noting that the “Constitution makes no reference to abortion, and no such right is implicitly protected by any constitutional provision,” so it was “time to heed the Constitution and return the issue of abortion to the people’s elected representatives.”
A month before, Politico published a leaked draft of Alito’s opinion, sparking intense outrage from pro-abortion activists. The Court soon confirmed the draft was authentic but stressed that it did not “represent a final decision by the court or the final position of any member on the issues in the case,” and announced the leak was under investigation.
During a recent interview with Fox News host Shannon Bream, Alito said he knew the decision would anger many people but did not anticipate the “most extreme forms” of backlash. “And I never dreamed the draft of the opinion would be leaked. That was totally unprecedented in the history of the country. It was a grave breach of the trust that everybody who worked in this building had before that point. It very predictably made the five of us in the majority targets for assassination. And nearly resulted in the assassination of my colleague Brett Kavanaugh.”
“You have an opinion about who you think the leaker was?” Bream followed up. Alito confirmed that he did, but he would not share their identity.
“I do have an opinion,” he said. “But the evidence available at this time is not strong enough for the court, or for me, to say.”
In January 2023, the Court released the investigation report by the marshal of the Supreme Court, U.S. Army attorney Col. Gail Curley, along with a statement by the Court and one by security consultant Michael Chertoff, a former judge and U.S. Secretary of Homeland Security, reviewing the investigation.
The marshal’s report states that “investigators have been unable to determine at this time, using a preponderance of the evidence standard, the identity of the person(s) who disclosed the draft majority opinion in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Org. or how the draft opinion was provided to Politico,” though investigators “continue to review and process some electronic data that has been collected and a few other inquiries remain pending. To the extent that additional investigation yields new evidence or leads, the investigators will pursue them.” The report also recommended new security measures to prevent future leaks.
Speculation has run rampant ever since as to whether the leaker genuinely evaded detection, or if his or her identity was simply too sensitive to divulge for who else it might implicate, potentially even left-wing members of the Court. But no evidence has ever emerged to translate conspiracy theories to fact.
Regardless, the fallout persists to this day.
Soon after the leak, a pro-abortion group calling itself Ruth Sent Us organized “walk-by protests” at the “homes of the six extremist justices” and published a map locating those homes. The protests, which included chants like “no uterus, no opinion” (despite Justice Amy Coney Barrett, who voted with Alito, being female), violated federal law against “picketing or parading” with the “intent of influencing any judge” in or near “a building or residence occupied or used by such judge.”
The Biden administration refused to condemn the choice of private homes as protest sites, and then-Democrat House Speaker Nancy Pelosi went so far as to praise the “righteous anger” of the protesters.
The leak and subsequent ruling were also followed by numerous acts of violence, vandalism, and intimidation against churches and pro-life pregnancy centers and, most alarmingly, California man Nicholas John Roske arriving with a gun and ammunition to the home of Kavanaugh. Last year, Roske was sentenced to just over eight years in prison, far short of the 30 years prosecutors had sought, with U.S. District Judge Deborah Boardman considering Roske’s “transgender” self-identification a mitigating factor in light of President Donald Trump’s executive order that gender-confused males not be housed with female inmates.
Conservative Justice Clarence Thomas has said the Dobbs leak struck a blow to “such a belief in the rule of law, belief in the court, a belief in what we were doing,” that “now that trust or that belief is gone forever.” Barrett says the physical threat level to the Court remains “really high.”