Featured Image
Bishop Rene Henry Gracida | Austen Ivereigh
Claire Chretien Claire Chretien Follow Claire

News

Bishop slams papal biographer who claimed Catholic converts are mentally ill

Claire Chretien Claire Chretien Follow Claire

August 11, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) – A retired Catholic bishop criticized Pope Francis's English biographer, Austen Ivereigh, for recently accusing converts to Catholicism of mental illness because they questioned the pope.

"The arrogance of the progressives who are the public voice for the present pontificate is nowhere more in evidence than in this current campaign of character assassination they are conducting against converts to the Catholic Faith," wrote Bishop Rene Henry Gracida, the Bishop Emeritus of the Diocese of Corpus Christi, on his blog.

Ivereigh accused converts and reverts who are critical of some of the actions and statements of Pope Francis of "convert neurosis." He praised Michael Sean Winters at the National Catholic Reporter for perpetuating this notion. Winters said that he's sick of converts "telling us that the Pope isn’t Catholic."

The narrative "of many of Francis’s angry, vociferous critics adds up to something rather like... that he is, in Ross Douthat’s phrase, the 'chief plotter' in a conspiracy to change the Catholic faith," wrote Ivereigh. 

But the retired Texas bishop said he has experienced converts as holding their Catholic faith more dear than anything else. 

"It has been my experience, and the experience of all of the bishops and priests that I have known that practically all of the converts to the faith that we have known are exemplars of the two characters in the two parables of Our Lord Jesus Christ: The Buried Treasure and The Pearl of Great Price," wrote Gracida.

Gracida shared his thoughts while commenting on an article on the controversy by Dr. Maike Hickson at One Peter Five

He noted the great personal price many converts pay upon embracing Catholicism.

"Like the man who found the treasure and who sold all that he had in order to buy the land where the treasure lay and the merchant who, having discovered the pearl of great value, sold all that he had in order to purchase that pearl[,] converts to the faith usually have to pay a great price in order to...profess the faith of the Roman Catholic Church," wrote Gracida. 

This price is often the "rejection they experience from their birth families," he observed. This often occurs if the convert was Jewish, Baptist, Adventist, or from a "fundamentalist" church, he said. 

Gracida explained how such a painful experience of rejection motivates converts to care about, and want to share, the Catholic faith.

"Having paid that emotional (and sometimes financial) price the convert is filled with extraordinary zeal, not only to practice the faith but to bear witness to the faith in a spirit of evangelization much more than cradle Catholics do," he wrote. 

"As a cradle Catholic, I can testify from my own experience when I, as is so often the case with cradle Catholics, did not realize the great value of the Tradition of the Church until I had strayed from the practice of my faith for a few years in my early 20’s," the retired bishop recalled.

But "when I came to my senses (in Salt Lake City, of all places) I returned to the practice of my faith with renewed vigor, eventually becoming a Benedictine monk, a priest and a bishop," he said. 

American Canon Lawyer Edward Peters called Ivereigh's article "one of the most embarrassing essays Crux has ever run."

Can you donate just $10 for PRO-LIFE?

Every person you help reach becomes equipped to engage in the culture war



Share this article

Advertisement

Customize your experience.

Login with Facebook