News
Featured Image
 Shutterstock

(LifeSiteNews) – A Christian family represented by Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) is suing Vermont education officials for discriminating against religious schools in state tuition assistance.

Vermont’s Town Tuition Program offers tuition aid to private secular schools in towns that had no public schools, but religious schools were initially excluded. Several families and the Diocese of Burlington filed two lawsuits, ultimately resulting in the government agreeing that such an exclusion was neither constitutional nor enforceable, and the Vermont Supreme Court agreed in 2022 to enforce a settlement allowing religious schools to access the program after the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals sided with parents the year before.

However, The Christian Post reported that Vermont effectively revived the restriction last year with Act 73, passing new rules that do not technically discriminate on the basis of religion but have the result of excluding all 12 religious schools that previously qualified from both the Town Tuition Program as well as the state’s Dual Enrollment Program, which lets high school students take college courses at no cost as long as they are also eligible for the Town Tuition Program.

Act 73’s new rules require qualifying schools to be in a district that does not have a public school for at least some grades, to have at least a quarter of its 2023-24 students funded by a public school district, and meet certain minimum class sizes. 

In response, ADF is suing the state in U.S. District Court for the District of Vermont, contending that the new rules are nothing more than a pretext to revive religious discrimination.

“Parents should be able to send their children to schools that are the best fit for them, and the First Amendment protects parents’ right to choose religious schools,” ADF Legal Counsel Jake Reed said. “Yet after decades and multiple court rulings protecting religious freedom, Vermont continues to discriminate against religious families and schools. Such unequal treatment violates the First Amendment, and government officials must be held accountable.”

“Vermont’s message is clear: Religious schools and their families are treated as second class in this state,” Reed added. “No religious school qualifies for Town Tuition funding, and no family who wants to send their kids to a religious school can reap the benefits of their own tax dollars. The First Amendment does not tolerate such treatment.”

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled 6-3 in 2022’s Carson v. Makin that a state-run program for tuition aid in Maine could not bar “sectarian” schools — religiously affiliated schools — from taking part in a similar program. The high court said in the case that excluding religious schools from tuition assistance violated the free exercise of religion assured by the First Amendment. 

As one of the most liberal states in the Union, Vermont is notoriously hostile to the rights of religious and traditionally conservative residents. In recent years, it has been forced to back down from attempts to restrict the speech of pro-life pregnancy centers, penalize girls’ athletic teams for refusing to play against biological males, and require foster families to “affirm” LGBT ideology.

3 Comments

  1. Loading...