Featured Image
Patient restrained in hospital bed.NoonVirachada /

SARASOTA, Florida – (LifeSiteNews) A Florida doctor who was hospitalized for COVID-19 claims that he was restrained in isolation and treated like a prisoner when he tried to get nursing staff to alert doctors to another COVID patient’s untreated pneumonia symptoms.

Dr. Stephen Guffanti said he was admitted to Sarasota Memorial Hospital August 2, after he had first developed COVID symptoms in late July. Guffanti, 70, is a retired physician who has worked as an emergency room physician, prison doctor and preventative medicine doctor.

He noticed that the patient next to him, a 51-year-old marathon runner, admitted the day after Guffanti was admitted, was getting worse while his own health was improving. The younger man’s breathing was impaired and Guffanti said he asked the runner if he wanted Guffanti to look at his medical chart.

“I could see that they missed the pneumonia. A first year resident would know it was bacterial pneumonia,” Guffanti told LifeSiteNews. He said he saw three blood tests showing increasing white blood cell counts and two X-ray reports indicating a worsening condition.

Guffanti said in a video interview with American Media Periscope that he asked the patient whose wife had died of cancer and who has three children if he wanted him to be his patient advocate. The unidentified patient agreed and Guffanti asked the nurses to call his doctor.

When the nurses refused to contact a doctor or to inform the patient of his doctor’s name, Guffanti said the patient agreed to have his picture posted on Facebook.

Patient at Sarasota Memorial, photographed by Dr. Guffanti

Guffanti said the nurses responded by telling him that they would be moving him to another room. Instead, he then asked to be released by signing an Against Medical Advice form—which would allow him to leave without being formally discharged by a doctor.

Guffanti told LifeSiteNews that hospital staff then physically restrained him in a hospital bed in an isolated room for four hours while they “decided what to do next.” He said that nurses laughed at him when he was forced to urinate in the bed while he was confined by four point restrictions. By mid- morning August 12, he said he was formally discharged.

At least six different nurses were involved and they were considering how to justify what they had done after they had done it, and not one of them said, “why don’t we just let him go home? This is a systemic problem.”

— Article continues below Petition —
PETITION: Support 2-year-old's right to remain on life support in UK
  Show Petition Text
6471 have signed the petition.
Let's get to 7500!
Thank you for signing this petition!
Add your signature:
  Show Petition Text
Keep me updated via email on this petition and related issues.
Keep me updated via email on this petition and related issues.

The parents of Alta Fixsler are pleading with the British courts not to remove life support from their brain-damaged daughter, so that they can transport her to a hospital in Israel or the U.S.

Could you do your part and SIGN and SHARE this petition which asks the British courts and hospital system to allow the Fixslers to remove their daughter from the UK so that she can live, and not be killed by so-called "passive euthanasia" where her life support is taken away?

Late last month, High Court Justice Mr. Alistair McDonald insanely ruled that it is in Alta's "best interests" to have her life support stopped, and that Manchester University NHS could begin the process of removing her life support.

But, Mr. and Mrs. Fixsler, who are are Orthodox Jews living according to Hebrew law, strenuously objected to the hospital depriving Alta of life support and she was given a reprieve, but we don't know how long that will last.

In fact, just yesterday, a British Court of Appeal declined to render judgement in this case, giving more hope that little Alta might be able to leave the UK and be treated in another country.

And, both American and Israeli lawmakers have spoken up against the planned passive euthanasia death of Alta, with a host of U.S. Senators, as well as the Israeli Health Minister and President, petitioning different British officials to stop the process of causing Alta's death.

We concur with what the Senators wrote: "It is unacceptable that people in government think they, not parents, should decide what is in the best interest of a child, even in a matter of life and death."

Please SIGN and SHARE this urgent petition now.

The story of a brain-damaged child in England in danger of a passive euthanasia opposed by both his or her parents and officials overseas is now a distressingly familiar one.

In the 2017 case of Charlie Gard, Pope Francis, President Donald Trump, and 37 European MPs sided with the infant’s parents against the British courts that agreed to allow the NHS to withdraw his life support. Almost one-year-old Charlie died 12 minutes after he was removed from a ventilator.

In 2018, Tom Evans, the Catholic father of Alfie Evans, appealed to Pope Francis on behalf of his almost two-year-old son, and the pontiff did indeed ask for prayers for the youngster. Both Polish and Italian hospitals were willing to treat the brain-injured boy, but the British courts refused to release him. Alfie died four days after he was removed from a ventilator.

In 2019, Tafida Raqeeb, then five years old, made headlines when her Muslim parents fought the Barts Health NHS Trust’s request to stop treating the brain-damaged girl. Once again, an Italian hospital offered to treat the sick child, and in this case the judge – Mr Justice Alistair MacDonald – ruled that the child could be allowed to live and taken to Italy for treatment.

And, in 2021, six-year-old Pippa Knight was not permitted to live despite the wishes of her widowed mother Paula. Pippa died in May after doctors removed her life support.

RIGHT NOW, please help little Alta and her parents fight for her right to live, and not be killed by having her life support removed.

Thank you for SIGNING and SHARING this urgent petition.


'No judgment yet: Panel to ‘think carefully’ about taking 2-year-old Alta Fixsler off life support' -

'US senators, Israeli officials appeal against UK High Court decision to deny Jewish toddler food, water, oxygen' -

'Judge rules Jewish girl's life support can be withdrawn' -

Photo Credit: screenshot / 'PA'

  Hide Petition Text

“The CEO of that hospital runs it like a prison and the patients are inmates,” Guffanti said.

“I’ve been a doctor for nearly 50 years and I can’t remember a time when the nursing staff was informed that a patient’s doctor needed to be notified and they refused to call or to even tell him who is doctor was.”

He said he has since joined a press conference at the hospital with others who are complaining to raise awareness about the situation. He told LifeSite Monday that he heard that the unnamed patient was treated with antibiotics and ventilated since. “His life is in their hands.”

Sarasota Memorial Hospital did not respond to a message from LifeSiteNews when contacted for comment.

A woman whose father is currently in the ICU in Sarasota Memorial Hospital told American Media Periscope that her family was taking legal action against the hospital.

Michelle Travares said her father went to the hospital with severe abdominal pain and tested positive for COVID-19 before any other diagnostics were done. Family members have been barred from seeing him since and staff has repeatedly “bullied and coerced” the family to allow him to be put on a ventilator, she said. When his wife refused to give permission to have her husband ventilated, a doctor hung up on her.

Travers said it is was one of her parents greatest fears to be hospitalized and separated from each other. “Imagining what he is going through right now without his partner by his side, I can’t even imagine the agony.”


Commenting Guidelines
LifeSiteNews welcomes thoughtful, respectful comments that add useful information or insights. Demeaning, hostile or propagandistic comments, and streams not related to the storyline, will be removed.

LSN commenting is not for frequent personal blogging, on-going debates or theological or other disputes between commenters.

Multiple comments from one person under a story are discouraged (suggested maximum of three). Capitalized sentences or comments will be removed (Internet shouting).

LifeSiteNews gives priority to pro-life, pro-family commenters and reserves the right to edit or remove comments.

Comments under LifeSiteNews stories do not necessarily represent the views of LifeSiteNews.