OTTAWA (LifeSiteNews) – The former head of the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) said Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s much-maligned internet censorship Bill C-11 should be shunned, calling it a “power grab over human communications.”
According to Blacklock’s Reporter, the comments were made by former CRTC commissioner Timothy Denton before a Senate committee hearing on Bill C-11 that took place Wednesday.
Critics have warned that Bill C-11 will stifle free speech online because it would classify YouTube videos, most of which are content-creator made, subject to regulation under the CRTC.
Both Bill C-11 and Bill C-18 seek to regulate the internet and force Big Tech companies to champion selected media outlets based on a special designation given by the federal government.
It is feared that Bill C-11 might force websites under the CRTC – including YouTube, Twitter, and Facebook – to remove content deemed “harmful” within 24 hours and compel services like Netflix to have more Canadian content.
Denton said that Trudeau’s C-11 “captures virtually all online audio and video.”
“(It’s) a power grab over human communications across the internet and therefore deserves our distinct disdain,” he noted.
Denton continued, saying that C-11 declares all “audio and visual content on the internet to be broadcasts.”
“It’s a kind of reverse takeover of the internet. The tiny Canadian broadcasting system can take on the world of the internet by the mere trick of redefining ‘broadcasting.’ C-11 is that bold and that absurd,” he added.
Denton, while speaking to the Senate transport and communications committee, noted that the internet establishes a worldwide market in “programming, video, sound and everything else.”
“It exists. It is the main and real thing in the world today.”
Dr. Michael Geist, a law professor at the University of Ottawa who is the Canada research chair in internet and E-commerce law, commented that Bill C-11 will allow the government’s broadcast regulator, the CRTC, a “virtually limitless reach” in what is deemed acceptable or not for programming.
On Wednesday, he released a blog that criticized many problem areas of Bill C-11.
“While some officials in Canadian Heritage Minister Pablo Rodriguez’s office have said their intent with the bill is to only cover the largest services with hundreds of thousands of subscribers, the bill does not include any such thresholds,” Geist noted.
“In fact, Liberal MPs rejected multiple amendment proposals to add a threshold to the bill.”
Geist added that the effect of C-11 could see some streaming services “block the Canadian market altogether” due to higher costs.
Big tech giants YouTube and Apple recently urged Canada’s senate to stall the passing of Bill C-11, which critics have warned will stifle free speech online.
Bill C-11 has been blasted by the official opposition in Canada, the Conservative Party, as legislation that will allow more government control of free speech through potential new draconian internet regulations.
Rodriguez introduced C-11, An Act to Amend the Broadcasting Act and to Make Related and Consequential Amendments to other Acts, in February.
Former CRTC head: Trudeau’s C-11 a ‘scheme’ to try and regulate the internet
Denton noted while speaking to the Senate transport and communications committee that Bill C-11 “is a scheme to try to make things that are utterly different and somehow give them the same regulatory treatment.”
“The internet does not really need regulatory treatment and the broadcasting system needs to adapt to the internet, not the internet to the Broadcasting Act,” he added.
John Lawford, executive director of the consumer group Public Interest Advocacy Centre, said that it’s “possible” over time Bill C-11 could target online groups based on their political leanings.
“(The CRTC) may have regulations which get into things like what’s appropriate speech,” Lawford said.
“They may get into things like how successful a station is or whether there is some sort of political bent that is not in favour at that particular time. It’s possible.”
Trudeau’s C-11 looks to grant the CRTC the power to regulate what are deemed “commercial” grade online music and videos but does not give a definition of what that means.
Bill C-11 passed the House of Commons in June by a 208-117 vote with support from the socialist NDP party and separatist Bloc Québécois.
The bill is now before Canada’s Senate for second reading, and it is anticipated the upper house vote on it this fall.
Some senators have said they will vote against Bill C-11.