ARMAGH, Ireland, July 5, 2013 ( – When Tom Barry, an Irish politician who considers himself pro-life, told Irish media that the Catholic Primate of Ireland had assured him he would face no ecclesiastical penalty for voting to legalize abortion, he spoke out of turn, according to a spokesman for Cardinal Sean Brady. has obtained an e-mail from a correspondent in Ireland sent by Fr. Michael C. Toner, diocesan secretary, that clarified the cardinal “had given him no assurances whatsoever and making clear the teaching of the Church as outlined by Blessed John Paul II in the Gospel of Life (Evangelium Vitae).” also confirmed the information with the executive director of the Council for Communications of the Irish Catholic Bishops’ Conference. Fr. Tim Bartlett said in an e-mail, “What I can confirm is that when Cardinal Brady read the reports of Mr Barry’s comments on his first letter, he was taken aback and wrote to him again to make it clear that no such assurances had been given or could be taken from his first letter and reminding him of the relevant aspects of Evangelium Vitae in terms of the grave and unmistakable responsibility on Catholic politicians when such legislation is proposed.”


Barry had told the Irish Examiner that he had written to both Brady and the papal nuncio, Charles Brown, and the cardinal had assured him he had nothing from an ecclesiastical point of view to worry about for supporting the bill.

“I received responses from both,” Barry told the Examiner. “But in particular, Cardinal Brady’s letter was very decent, telling me not be to be concerned but outlining his and the Church’s views on the matter.”

Click “like” if you want to end abortion!

The papal encyclical, Evangelium Vitae, by Pope John Paul II, prohibits any Catholic politician from supporting legislation that liberalizes abortion laws, and the Church’s Code of Canon Law specifically states that those “obstinately persevering in manifest grave sin are not to be admitted to holy communion.” The encyclical says that “a person who actually procures an abortion incurs automatic (latae sententiae) excommunication”..

“The excommunication affects all those who commit this crime with knowledge of the penalty attached, and thus includes those accomplices without whose help the crime would not have been committed,” the encyclical continues.

In his letter to US bishops in 2004, the former Cardinal Ratzinger wrote that politicians, who were at the time in a campaign for the presidency, “must” be refused Communion if they persist in supporting abortion legislation after receiving due instruction from the clergy.

Monsignore Ignacio Barreiro, head of the Rome office of Human Life International, told that the threat of the abortion bill is only a symptom of the longer-term erosion of Catholic Christian life and belief in Ireland.

He said that the immediate cause of the bill having been brought forward, has been the shock of the sexual abuse scandals, and the loss of prestige of the Church that resulted. The larger, longer-term cause, however, has been the more general crisis of faith and moral values that followed the Second Vatican Council II in the 1960s. What is needed, he said, is more than just pro-life political campaigns against this or that piece of legislation or immediate threat, but a massive “re-evangelization” of Ireland.

The first key, he said, is restoring discipline within the Church, both among clerics and the laity. “The bishops must refuse Holy Communion to politicians who support abortion,” he told LifeSiteNews. He cited the comments made by Raymond Cardinal Burke, the head of the Vatican’s Apostolic Signatura, the “supreme court” of the Catholic Church, and the most authoritative interpreter of Canon Law.

In February, Cardinal Burke said, “There can be no question that the practice of abortion is among the gravest of manifest sins and therefore once a Catholic politician has been admonished that he should not come forward to receive Holy Communion.”

Not only should he not come forward himself, “as long as he continues to support legislation which fosters abortion or other intrinsic evils, then he should be refused Holy Communion,” the cardinal added.

The correction from Cardinal Brady comes as the Irish parliament passed the government’s abortion bill, which proposes to legalize abortion through all nine months of pregnancy, in a vote of 138-24. Barry has said he supports the legislation, echoing the claim of Enda Kenny’s government that the bill merely “clarifies” the existing law. The government has claimed that the bill’s abortion provision falls within the limits of the constitution that allows medical procedures for serious medical reasons for pregnant women, even if it may result in the unintended death of her unborn child.

But the bill contains a provision that allows abortion, the direct intentional killing of the child, at any stage of pregnancy, in cases where the mother has threatened suicide. The government has continued to push the bill forward, despite nearly all the expert and medical testimony during the hearings that said abortion can never be considered treatment for any medical or psychological condition.

The Irish bishops have issued a statement opposing the bill, titled the “Protection of Life During Pregnancy Act,” and calling on Catholics to oppose it.