A LifeSite property

Bringing you the news from a traditional Catholic perspective.

News
Featured Image
 Sebastian Duda/Shutterstock

(LifeSiteNews) — Author Joyce Carol Oates has mocked the Catholic doctrine on transubstantiation and claimed that author Flannery O’Connor did not believe in the Real Presence.

The 88-year-old liberal novelist wrote on X that “the Catholic mass, for instance, is supposed to be literal (i.e., literally the blood & body of Christ); but of course, everyone understands that it is metaphorical. Some measure of progress in civilization at least.”

An X user replied to her post, stating, “Transubstantiation [is] not a symbol, as Flannery O’Connor famously pointed out.”

Oates answered: “Yes, to be contrarian. But obviously no one, even a ‘devout Catholic,’ which is what O’Connor called herself, seriously believes that the communion wafer isn’t a wafer. If you even believed that the wafer was soaked in someone’s actual DNA, you would not want to take it into your mouth & let it melt on your tongue.”

Many users in the comments pointed out that Oates clearly misunderstands Catholic sacramental theology.

Conservative commentator Michael Knowles wrote, “It’s one thing to deny transubstantiation. (Not an advisable thing, but understandable.) However, if you’re going to make sweeping claims about it, you should at least attempt to understand the basic elements of the idea, such as the distinction between substance and accidents.”

Ulrich Lehner, a Catholic professor at Notre Dame University, told Oates, “I would be embarrassed if I spoke so uninformed.”

Other users on X added a “community note,” used to correct false claims on the platform or offer additional context. The note states: “Flannery O’Connor did not believe the Eucharist was merely ‘symbolic’ or ‘metaphorical,’ contrary to Oates’ claim. O’Connor repeatedly stated the Catholic belief that although the wafer has the physical qualities (‘accidents’) of bread, its true substance is Jesus Christ.”

O’Connor famously said: “Well, if it’s a symbol, to hell with it!” The novelist was an outspoken defender of Christ’s Real Presence in the Eucharist.

31 Comments

  1. Loading...