Liberal senators silent on how ‘Medicare for all’ would have handled Alfie Evans
May 4, 2018 (The Daily Signal) – Sixteen liberal lawmakers who support a "Medicare for all" plan declined to respond to The Daily Signal on how they anticipate cases such as that of British toddler Alfie Evans should be handled in the United States.
The Daily Signal requested comment from Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., and 15 cosponsors of his legislation before the Senate Finance Committee that would make the Medicare program available to all Americans and increase the government's influence in health care decisions.
Sanders, a self-described democratic socialist who sought the Democratic nomination for president in 2016, caucuses with the Democrats. His 15 co-sponsors are all Democrats.
The Daily Signal emailed the Senate offices of Sanders and co-sponsors Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin, Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut, Cory Booker of New Jersey, Kirsten Gillibrand of New York, Kamala Harris of California, Martin Heinrich of New Mexico, Mazie Hirono of Hawaii, Patrick Leahy of Vermont, Edward Markey of Massachusetts, Jeff Merkley of Oregon, Brian Schatz of Hawaii, Jeanne Shaheen of New Hampshire, Tom Udall of New Mexico, Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts, and Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island.
In emails sent to the 16 senators Monday and Tuesday, The Daily Signal noted that they have advocated government-run health care and asked what they thought of the Alfie Evans case and how a similar case should be handled in the United States.
None had responded as of publication deadline Tuesday evening.
Bob Moffit, a senior health care analyst for The Heritage Foundation, told The Daily Signal that England's universal health care system is to blame for Alfie's death.
"In the British system, the government arrogated to itself the final say over the child's fate, not his loving parents, and in the process coldly repudiating the charitable provision of potential medical alternatives," Moffit said in a written statement, adding:
The British courts, of course, sided with the British government and its National Health Service personnel. Americans must be on guard to make sure that government officials are never given such arbitrary power, power over life and death, denying the right of patients to go outside of the system and secure alternative sources of care or better medical treatment.
His doctors acted under the guidelines of the National Health Service, England's government-sponsored universal health care system. According to The Sun, the courts deemed that Alfie "could not be saved" and that it would be "unkind" and "futile" to pursue treatment.
Alder Hey Children's Hospital ended Alfie's treatment and removed him from a ventilator.
His parents, Kate James and Thomas Evans, had taken their legal fight to keep him on life support to the British Court of Appeal, the British Supreme Court, and the European Court of Human Rights.
On April 20, Britain's High Court denied Alfie's parents' final appeal that they be allowed to continue to care for Alfie, ordering the hospital to remove his life support on April 23.
Published with permission from The Daily Signal.