News

NDP won’t force Alberta’s Catholic healthcare facilities to euthanize – yet

‘We do reserve the right to change our approach,’ they say.
Wed Jun 1, 2016 - 4:40 pm EST
Featured Image
Alberta Premier Rachel Notley Don Voaklander, CC

EDMONTON, June 1, 2016 (LifeSiteNews) — Alberta’s NDP government will not compel the province’s Catholic-run Covenant Health facilities to kill patients through euthanasia and assisted suicide, according to Associate Health Minister Brandy Payne.

“We are not taking a heavy hand in enforcement,” Payne told the Alberta legislature Tuesday, when tabling a motion for draft regulations on euthanasia and assisted suicide.

“We do reserve the right to change our approach if it becomes unmanageable and patients wishing to access this right cannot do so, but we are moving forward in a way that is as respectful as it can be to all people in Alberta,” she added.

Premier Rachel Notley’s NDP majority is “working to set out a framework of protocols and processes to ensure that if a patient in a facility where medical assistance in dying is not available, that there will be a process in place for transfer of care likely through Alberta Health Services,” Payne told reporters Monday.

Payne submitted Tuesday’s motion with a view to the June 6 deadline, when the Supreme Court’s Carter decision striking down the law against euthanasia and assisted suicide takes effect. The federal bill legalizing euthanasia and assisted suicide, Bill C-14, was passed by the House later the same day, and is now before the Senate.

“Our responsibility in this matter is actually quite small and specifically relates to the framework for medical providers and patients,” she told the legislature.

Covenant Health, a province-wide healthcare conglomerate administered by the Catholic Church, runs 18 hospitals, independent living and extended care facilities in 12 Alberta communities.

Its board members include Edmonton’s Archbishop Richard Smith and former premier Ed Stelmach.

Smith and his five fellow Alberta bishops condemned euthanasia and assisted suicide in a February 11, 2016 statement that declared Catholic health facilities would not kill their patients.

Some two weeks later, the federal joint parliamentary committee released its report recommending all publicly funded health care institutions be compelled to provide euthanasia and assisted suicide.

The bishops sent Payne a strongly worded submission in March, asserting that the “Catholic Church and her institutions will always serve the vulnerable and suffering in our society” but “we cannot as individuals and as institutions participate in, condone or advocate for physician assisted suicide or euthanasia.”

Covenant Health reiterated that in a May 24, 2016 statement on its website.

The Catholic corporation’s “ethical and moral opposition to medical assistance in dying” and its “unequivocal position to not provide or explicitly refer for same needs to be recognized, respected and honoured by all persons served by, or working within Covenant Health including, but not limited to: funders, regulatory bodies, advocacy groups and the larger community,” it reads.

However, a “response to both a patient’s consented request and an external provider arrangement to assume care of the patient” may “require safe and timely transfer of the patient and their records to a non-objecting institution for continued exploratory discussion and assessment,” the statement reads.

Timothy Wilson, press director for Alberta’s Health Ministry, said that conscientiously objecting institutions “will be required to transfer patient care to our health authority, Alberta Health Services, which will coordinate access and support for the patient.

The pro-euthanasia lobby has loudly decried the NDP’s decision.

Dying with Dignity Canada’s CEO Shanaaz Gokool stated that “taxpayer-funded institutions” have “no right” to conscientiously object to providing euthanasia or assisted suicide, while its Edmonton spokesperson Brad Peter told MetroNews that in some towns, the only hospital is Catholic — as is the case in Camrose, Vegreville, Bonnyville, and Banff.

“In some scenarios, an individual might have to leave the community they’re in because there exists no other hospital facility other than Covenant Health,” said Peter.

Covenant Health President and CEO Patrick Dumelie countered that physicians and staff of Covenant Health agree to the healthcare corporation’s Catholic position when they sign on.

“All of our physicians and health professionals understand our faith and our belief and our ethics,” he told MetroNews.

People opposed to euthanasia and assisted suicide also pay taxes and are “members of the public,” point out the bishops in their March brief.

Many people do not want to be killed by medical means, and if a healthcare institution does so as a “service,” that will “radically change” the “trust its clients place upon it, and what they expect from it,” they wrote.

Euthanasia advocates may paint the Church as “callous, inhumane, perhaps moralistic or cruel” for taking this stance, but “centuries of pastoral practice have taught us that suicide and killing, even natural death itself, do not end suffering,”stated the bishops.

“In fact, all attempts to deny suffering, or to hide or sanitize it, simply do not work. All that euthanasia and assisted suicide can do is pass suffering on to others.”

Opposition MLAs criticized the NDP for not acting sooner, noting the Legislature adjourns June 2.

“I believe it is shocking that with fewer than 72 hours left in the spring session as scheduled, the NDP has tabled crucial documents directly related to the life and death of Albertans,” stated Calgary-Lougheed PC Dave Rodney, “and dedicated a mere six hours to the most important decision of any person’s life.”


  alberta, carter decision, catholic, euthanasia, rachel notley

Keep this news available to you and millions more

Your gift will spread truth, defeat lies, and save lives


Share this article