Physician-trained cardinal: Hormones, surgery won’t help transgender people
May 17, 2019 (LifeSiteNews) — Only a male can represent Christ in conferring the sacraments of Holy Eucharist and Confession, His Eminence Cardinal Willem Jacobus Eijk of the Netherlands told the Rome Life Forum Thursday during a Q&A period.
The archbishop of Utrecht responded to the inquiry of how Catholics should react should Rome permit the ordination of women as deacons. Eijk reaffirmed Church teaching and principles as well when asked about responding to bishops who support the LGBT agenda, and also regarding gender ideology encountered by children in school.
Eijk opened the Rome Life Forum Thursday with an address that warned of the threat “gender theory” poses to the traditional family and the Christian faith.
The question on female deacons reflected the ongoing push for women’s ordination both to the diaconate and to the priesthood — though neither is possible, according to the Church’s tradition of an all-male priesthood as ordained by Christ himself, which Eijk confirmed.
“I firmly believe that the Holy Spirit will prevent Rome from saying that women can be ordained deacons,” the cardinal said. “And that’s not because I have disdain for women, absolutely not. That’s of course because of our theology.”
“A priest has to represent Christ in person, and Jesus was a man,” Eijk explained. “So only as a man, as a male, you can represent Christ in person in celebrating the Holy Eucharist and hearing Confessions. For this reason I think that the Holy Spirit will not permit the Roman Magisterium to say women can become ordained deacons.”
The question on female deacons followed the conclusion of a commission established by Pope Francis, which Eijk referenced. The pope had directed the commission to study the role of women in the Church historically, and the group did not reach agreement on the question of a female diaconate, to the disappointment of left-leaning Catholics.
“And you know we have only one sacrament of ordination,” Eijk said, with three degrees: deacon, priest, and bishop. “In all these degrees, you can only participate only when you are male.”
Asked how Catholics should respond when their children are confronted at school with gender ideology, Eijk said first by prayer, but also by example. “I should say above all by praying and by witnessing.”
The cardinal explained that parents are the first educators of their children, and children will learn from their parents’ witness of faith.
The very act of taking one’s children to Mass, even when they are young and can be difficult to manage, is important, said Eijk. He said as well that children are able to process rational explanations. When you take them to church and teach them to pray, Eijk added, they will learn about sacral things without you even realizing.
“And that’s the first thing,” he said. “You have to witness (to) your faith.”
In many cases the world may be stronger and will win, he continued. “But nevertheless, our duty is to bear witness to the Gospel of Christ,” he said, and “also to what the Church says about the relationship between gender and sex.”
Eijk stressed prayer again in response to gender ideology pushed in schools, imploring, “But continue to pray, please.”
The cardinal was also asked during the Q&A about how to approach bishops who promote, support, and allow the LGBT agenda to be part of their Catholic communities.
“There is a great confusion in the Church and perhaps even bishops are sometimes receptive for that,” he replied. “We have to pray. But also we have to bear witness to the truth.”
Laymen have their influence, too, Eijk added, encouraging Catholics away from shyness in approaching bishops.
“Don’t be shy,” he said, “and also witness to your bishops.”
Eijk, who was trained as a physician prior to ordination, along with having a doctorate in philosophy and a doctorate in theology, was asked how he would treat a patient who was thinking about attempting to change his sex.
“When people are suffering from (what) one calls gender dysphoria, you have to take them seriously, because people are suffering,” he said.
We have to admit that we have transgenders in our midst, he added, and also Catholic transgenders.
Individuals suffering with gender dysphoria must be offered psychological support, the cardinal responded, specifically psychotherapy.
“The answer is not hormonal treatment and above all (not) surgery,” he stated. “Surgery is not the good answer for a psychological problem.”
The patient must accept what the problem is for actual help to be rendered, Eijk said. “In a friendly way, I will try to understand them and take them seriously in their problems. … But you know, at a certain moment, when they don’t accept psychological support, then at a certain moment I would have to witness my faith, and of my view of their relationship between the sensual aspects of gender and biological sexuality.”
In a recent comprehensive interview with LifeSiteNews, Eijk discussed his efforts in seeking clarity from Pope Francis related to confusion stemming from the pope's controversial exhortation Amoris laetitia, along with other issues including intercommunion with Protestants.
Eijk was also among the prelates who called for full investigation of former U.S. apostolic nuncio Carlo Maria Viganò’s claims in Viganò’s testimony last summer implicating Francis and other high-level churchmen in covering for accused serial sexual predator Theodore McCarrick.
The fifth annual Rome Life Forum runs May 16–17. Click here for information on livestreaming the addresses at the Forum.