(LifeSiteNews) — Father Davide Pagliarani, the Society of St. Pius X’s (SSPX) superior general, defended the position of the traditional priestly society after the Vatican’s declared excommunication of its bishops, asserting that they “told the truth” to the pope.
Speaking at the Priory of Our Lady of Sorrows in Roodepoort, South Africa, on September 19, Pagliarani clarified that, contrary to reports that the Vatican had satisfactory discussions with the SSPX leading up to the consecrations, their communication was in fact poor.
“(The SSPX) simply chose to tell the truth to everybody — first of all to the pope, telling him, ‘Listen, we cannot agree.’ We explained why we were going to consecrate bishops … and we made a profession of faith.”
SSPX Superior General Fr. Davide Pagliarani speaking at the… pic.twitter.com/OwXXnrNu5E
— Integrity Magazine (@IntegritasMag) September 22, 2026
“We just (chose), since the very beginning, to tell the truth, to everybody,” said Pagliarani, Integrity Magazine reported.
“To the pope first, telling him, ‘Listen, we cannot agree.’ There is another solution, understanding. We told the truth to the pope. And we told the truth to people.”
“We explained why we were going to consecrate the bishops, why they are needed, and we made the profession of faith. Two professions of faith. Why? Because that was the way to tell the truth. That’s what they need,” he continued.
While in the weeks leading up to the episcopal consecrations, Pagliarani was granted an audience with Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández, the heterodox prefect of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith (DDF), Pope Leo XIV would not meet with SSPX leadership.
A February communiqué from the SSPX General House published after Pagliarani’s meeting with Fernández claimed that the cardinal proposed dialogue with the SSPX to clarify the “minimum necessary” for the SSPX’s canonical status. The cardinal had already made clear that the Second Vatican Council documents must be accepted in full by the SSPX to reach such “regular” status.
“The Cardinal stated orally that, while it would be possible to engage in dialogue about the Council, its texts could not be corrected,” the communiqué said.
The SSPX has been denied “regularization” and the approval of their episcopal consecrations by the Vatican because it insists on clearly calling out Vatican II’s contradictions of perennial Church teaching such as its declaration “that the human person has a right to religious freedom.”
In fact, Archbishop Guido Pozzo, the former head of the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei, clarified in 2016 that some texts of the Second Vatican Council that are not doctrinal and are thus not binding on the Catholic conscience. Pozzo specifically named texts with which the SSPX takes issue, including Nostra Aetate on interreligious dialogue; the decree Unitatis Redintegratio on ecumenism; and the Declaration Dignitatis Humanae on religious liberty, and explained:
They are not about doctrines or definitive statements, but, rather, about instructions and orienting guides for pastoral practice. On can (thus legitimately) continue to discuss these pastoral aspects after the (proposed) canonical approval (of the SSPX) in order to lead us to further (and acceptable) clarifications.
The SSPX Superior General had emphasized during his talk in South Africa that what souls need most today, “because they cannot find it anywhere,” is “the truth.”
