‘No different than infanticide’: Pro-life leaders respond to New York legalizing abortion to birth
PETITION: Say "NO" to celebrating abortion by lighting up One World Trade Center! Sign the petition here.
January 23, 2019 (LifeSiteNews) – Pro-life leaders and commentators are responding with disgust, sorrow, and resolve to the New York legislature’s votes Tuesday evening to enshrine a “fundamental right” to abortion in state law and strip protections from preborn babies until birth.
The state Senate voted 38-24 and the state Assembly 92-47 yesterday in favor of the so-called “Reproductive Health Act,” a bill that has repeatedly cleared the Assembly in years past but been blocked by the formerly-Republican Senate. Democrat Gov. Andrew Cuomo, who signed the bill, called it a “historic victory for New Yorkers and our progressive values” and ordered the One World Trade Center spire to be lit in pink to mark the occasion.
The bill declares that “Every individual who becomes pregnant has the fundamental right to choose to carry the pregnancy to term, to give birth to a child, or to have an abortion,” erases the state’s recognition of preborn babies older than 24 weeks as potential homicide victims, removes abortion from the penal code entirely, and allows licensed health practitioners other than full doctors to commit abortions.
The Times-Union suggests the bill would allow “late-stage” abortions only if the mother’s “health” is endangered or if the baby is deemed non-viable, but the New York State Right to Life Committee warns that the bill would go much further in practice.
Declaring abortion a “fundamental right” opens the door to invalidating “any limits on abortion” and “mandat[ing] that everyone take part in the culture of death,” the group warns. The bill would also prevent pregnant women whose babies are killed in violent attacks from seeing justice, and have the effect of “authorizing infanticide” by repealing the requirement that a second physician be on hand in the event that an attempted abortion past twenty weeks yields a live infant.
Many pro-life observers registered their disapproval Tuesday and continued to do so Wednesday.
“We commend those who voted to defend the unborn and their mothers, and speak out in debate. RHA is an extreme bill sold to the public saying it merely 'updates' New York's law, which is far from true,” New York State Right to Life responded in a statement. “NYSRTL will continue to work to expose the misinformation put forth about RHA, protect children and their mothers, protect the rights of pro-life persons to engage in life-saving activities and express their views, and to build a culture of Life in New York.”
“Convicted criminals aren’t subjected to the death penalty in New York state, but now children up until the ninth month of pregnancy can be given lethal injections and poisoned to death,” said Live Action founder and president Lila Rose. “This is no different than infanticide.”
“One thing that this law reveals to the nation is the extent and the extremism of the 1973 Roe v. Wade decision, which allows laws such as this one to exist. It was Roe that legalized abortion through all nine months of pregnancy in this country,” continued Rose. “If Roe is not soon overturned, any state could follow New York’s monstrous example.”
“Already the nation's abortion capital, New York’s pro-abortion Dems just passed the most radical abortion bill in the nation,” the pro-life Radiance Foundation said, noting the state’s abortion laws were already permissive and the change will mean “zero regulations from facility inspections to parental consent/notifications to requirement of actual doctor to commit the abortion to any limits on taxpayer funding of it.”
“Governor Cuomo ordered One World Trade Center--a memorial to the thousands killed by senseless violence and hate--to be lit up in pink to celebrate the unrestricted violence of abortion that treats the unborn with more antipathy than criminals,” Radiance noted. “God help us.”
Late term abortion is now legal in New York. Capital punishment is illegal. Which means it is only okay to give lethal injection to infants. If that seems rational or moral to you, you're a psychopath.— Matt Walsh (@MattWalshBlog) January 23, 2019
The Susan B. Anthony List told Cuomo and New York “shame on you,” while highlighting the grim irony of the top of the World Trade Center building being used to celebrate abortion while the memorial below it recognizes eleven preborn children killed in the September 11 terrorist attacks.
How tragic: @NYGovCuomo orders World Trade Center to be lit pink to celebrate new law in New York permitting unborn babies to be killed by abortion up until birth...— Susan B. Anthony List (@SBAList) January 23, 2019
...while the WTC memorial below bears the names of 11 unborn children who lost their lives in the 9/11 attacks pic.twitter.com/GSoBHKxva7
Abby Johnson, a former Planned Parenthood worker turned pro-life activist, struck a tone of encouragement, saying that while pro-lifers could “wallow in this tragedy” and “perpetually grieve the lives lost,” we “must continue to press forward. Lives continue to be on the line, and we will be there to provide the support these women need. Pregnancy centers will continue to be open. Prayer warriors will continue to line the sidewalks in front of abortion facilities.”
Students for Life of America president Kristan Hawkins blasted the Planned Parenthood Action Fund for celebrating “genocide,” and compared a clip of cheering in the state Senate to Nazi Germany:
Ever see those clips of Nazi party conventions? https://t.co/w7fFnw9k2v— Kristan Hawkins (@KristanHawkins) January 23, 2019
Repealing the law will depend on future elections, but in the meantime a portion of the attention has turned to what this means for the Catholic identification of Cuomo and other pro-abortion politicians in the state.
I was ordained into the Priesthood in New York and am disgusted that my state would open the #Abortion floodgates up until birth. We must raise our voices louder than ever and oppose the intentional killing of precious babies. The Church must stand and push to overturn #RoeVsWade— Fr. Frank Pavone ���� (@frfrankpavone) January 23, 2019
The New York State Catholic Conference released a statement noting that many of the lawmakers who supported the bill “are mothers themselves, who felt their child toss, turn and kick in their womb”; “are fathers, who held their partner’s hand as they viewed the ultrasound videos, watched their child squirm and rejoiced at the first sound of a heartbeat”; and “were themselves born into less-than-perfect conditions – poverty, health problems, disabilities, broken families.”
The conference called on Catholics to pray “for the conversion of heart for those who celebrate this tragic moment in the history of our state,” and “for the lives that will be lost, and for the women of our state who are made less safe under this law.” Others argue the Church should do more, however.
If Andrew Cuomo remains a "Catholic in good standing" after signing this abortion bill then the Church's institutional witness to life simply has zero teeth and the US bishops have completely abdicated their responsibilities as shepherd of souls. No other way to square it, folks.— Thomas Peters (@AmericanPapist) January 23, 2019
“One needs to immediately question why Governor Cuomo has not been rightfully disciplined and denied Holy Communion by the Albany Bishop, Bishop Edward Scharfenberger, or by New York's Cardinal Timothy Dolan,” Barbara Kralis wrote at Renew America. “The Albany Bishop can talk about Cuomo until his mitre floats down the Hudson River, but it will make little difference” without enforcing “the Church's well-defined canon laws already in place.”