Dec. 10, 2013 (FRC) – As the owner of Masterpiece Cakes, Jack Phillips is used to making batter. What he's not used to is being battered for his beliefs. Unfortunately for Jack, the two now go hand in hand under a ruling many would argue is its own masterpiece of religious intolerance. The case had been brewing since July 2012, when two homosexuals stormed out of Phillips's shop, irate that Jack wouldn't make a cake for their upcoming “wedding.”

Despite Jack's polite decline and an offer to sell them pastries for “any other occasion,” Charlie Craig and David Mullins left the bakery determined to make an example out of the Christian owners. Hours later, the threatening phone calls started — followed by death threats, boycotts, protests outside the shop, and eventually, a lawsuit. For the 40-year-old business, a fixture of the Denver community for over a generation, it was a defining moment. “My decision not to participate in the gay weddings is not motivated by politics,” Jack explained, “or hatred of gays, though I've been accused of [that]. My decision is based solely on a desire to live my life in obedience to God and His word.”

But to Colorado Judge Robert Spencer, Jack's rights — and those of thousands of other Christian businessmen — are not what matters. What matters is Americans' ideological conformity on an issue that contradicts the teachings of every mainstream world religion. To Judge Spencer, surrendering those beliefs is just the price of doing business in a politically correct market. “Conceptually,” Spencer wrote, “[Jack Phillips's] refusal to serve a same-sex couple due to religious objection to same-sex weddings is no different from refusing to serve a biracial couple because of religious objection to biracial marriage.”

Like most activist judges, Spencer tries to equate sexual behavior with skin color, a comparison with no basis in science — or logic. What's more, he tied the case to a Supreme Court suit involving Bob Jones University, in which the justices stripped the college's tax status over its rule against biracial relationships. But, as FRC's Ken Klukowski pointed out, Jack's case is an enormous leap from that decision because the Supreme Court never told Bob Jones that it couldn't hold those views. It simply stripped the university's tax exemption. In Jack's case, the judge is ordering the bakery to abandon his beliefs (in a state that defines marriage the same way Jack does) — or else. “Cease and desist from discrimination,” he ruled, or face punishment (which, until recently, included jail time).


Sound familiar? It should. The President's HHS mandate insists on the same kind of viewpoint capitulation. Of course, the logical conclusion of this “marriage mandate” is that the government can force businesses to participate in anything it wants them to. “If the government can tell Jack what to think and say, that is a government we should fear,” said Phillips's attorney, Nicolle Martin.

In both instances — the HHS mandate and marriage — Americans are being required to do something the Founders never intended: separate their values from their vocations. If Jack Phillips, Barronelle StutzmanElaine Huguenin, or Hobby Lobby want to serve the Lord full time, the First Amendment encourages it. What it doesn't encourage are judges like Spencer, who trample Americans' rights as a way of inventing others. “I'm a huge supporter of gay rights, gay weddings, gay marriage,” said Denver talk show host Peter Boyles, “but these guys are wrong and Masterpiece Cakes is right. [Jack] doesn't say, 'You can't come in here and buy;' he says, 'I'm not going to make you a cake of two men getting married.' As much as I support two men getting married, I support his right to say no.”

So do 85% of Americans, who agreed that vendors like Christian wedding photographers should be able to turn down jobs if they had strongly-held beliefs on same-sex “marriage.” Now, instead of turning down work, some may have to discontinue theirs altogether. “If Jack can't make wedding cakes,” his attorney pointed out, “he can't continue to support his family. And in order to make wedding cakes, Jack must violate his belief system. That is a reprehensible choice.”

Click “like” if you support TRADITIONAL marriage.

Tragically, it's a choice more Christians are having to make in industries like counselingbroadcastingeducationsmall business, and even the military, where conservative views are consistently squeezed out. As far as Masterpiece Cakes is concerned, friends say the Phillipses are in good spirits despite the ruling. Serving customers is important, but these bakers believe serving God matters more.

Reprinted with permission from the Family Research Council.