June 8, 2016 (Alex Schadenberg) -- Me Before You has become one of the controversial films of the decade, with protests, boycotts and many articles about the film. Not Dead Yet organized protests outside movie theaters, EPC asked its supporters to boycott the film in order to not give the makers of this movie our hard earned cash, nonetheless, the clearest voices have been disability leaders.
John Kelly
John Kelly, the New England Regional Director for Not Dead Yet, who has read the book, was reported by the New Boston Post as saying:
“After a new injury, people are very vulnerable, because suddenly you become part of a marginalized group,” And in terms of the film, “Only a disabled character could have their suicide presented as noble. Imagine if another character in the movie had killed themselves based on their own internalized depression.”
“People happily cry over people like me killing ourselves,”
“Where are the films where he changes his mind and they live happily ever after?”
Dominick Evans
Dominick Evans, was interviewed by Montgomery Jones for Film Obsession. Evans is a movie director and critic. Evans stated:
The disability community is really worried about what this is going to say to a newly disabled person. No one is disputing how vulnerable it can be to go from being able to move physically and suddenly being disabled. It is a huge transition, and that is why a lot of rehabilitation centers look for anxiety and depression, because those things need to be treated. If a person is non-disabled and they are suicidal, we do everything in our power to give them a reason to want to live. Why are we not seeing the same level of care and concern for disabled people? Why is it just accepted without question that disabled people should be allowed to kill themselves, and why is there this default belief that disability = suffering? We deserve just as much right to suicide prevention as any other person.
When I was 19 years old because of years of systemic abuse and oppression which I endured from my family, my school, and my community as a disabled person, and as an LGBT person, I tried to kill myself. I am so grateful today that I did not make it through the process. I hear this over and over from my disabled friends who have tried to kill themselves. Many of us become depressed because of how we are treated by society, especially when it is our families, and other loved ones. That depression needs to be treated, and disabled people are not receiving that kind of care.
Ella Frech
The comments by Ella Frech, really hit home. Frech, who will soon be 12-years-old and is a wheel chair athlete, wrote an article for Aleteia.org:
Well, what’s wrong with a life that looks like mine?
My mom says this isn’t the first movie where a handicapped person had to die for being paralyzed. There was one called Million Dollar Baby where a woman is a quad and bravely chooses death instead of an imperfect life. So I’m asking you again, what’s wrong with my life? Why do you think I should want to die? You sit there with your able bodies, and look at people in chairs and think you feel pity for our sad little lives, but the truth is you’re afraid. You don’t want to imagine that you might be one of us one day. You think you can be perfect, and think you’d rather die than have parts that don’t work right. I think that’s sad.
LifeSiteNews welcomes thoughtful, respectful comments that add useful information or insights. Demeaning,
hostile or propagandistic comments, and streams not related to the storyline, will be removed.
LSN commenting is not for frequent personal blogging, on-going debates or theological or other disputes
between commenters.
Multiple comments from one person under a story are discouraged (suggested maximum of three). Capitalized
sentences or comments will be removed (Internet shouting).
LifeSiteNews gives priority to pro-life, pro-family commenters and reserves the right to edit or
remove comments.
Comments under LifeSiteNews stories do not necessarily represent the views of LifeSiteNews.
